KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
DOI 10.1007/S12225-014-9488-Y
ISSN: 0075-5974 (print)
ISSN: 1874-933X (electronic)
A synopsis of the genus Pteronia (Compositae: Astereae) in Namibia
including the resurrection of Pteronia quadrifaria
Herta Kolberg1 & Michiel van Slageren2
Summary. An account of species of Pteronia occurring in Namibia is presented, together with an updated key. New
material of P. quadrifaria Dinter confirmed that this is a valid species and not a synonym of P. lucilioides DC., and is
resurrected. Species descriptions, global and Namibian distributions, conservation status, habitat and phenological
information are presented for the 24 species recognised from Namibia. During this study it became clear that
many species names have not been properly typified. As a result arguments are presented for the choice of 10
lectotypes, eight of which concern Pteronia with five of these for names of species accepted here. Four species of
Pteronia that have been described from or are at least partly occurring in Namibia but that are no longer considered part of this genus are briefly discussed.
Key Words. Asteraceae, key, lectotypes, southern Africa, taxonomy.
Introduction
During fieldwork for the Millennium Seed Bank Project
in the south-west of Namibia in 2009, a species of Pteronia
L. (Compositae: Astereae) unknown to the first author
was found on a white quartz hill near the small town of
Aus. After initial investigation and consultation with
various specialists, it seemed that this plant represented a
new species of the genus. Since the only published
account of the Compositae for the flora of Namibia
(Merxmüller 1967) is outdated and needs to be revised,
it was decided to combine description of this presumed
new species with a synopsis and updated key of Pteronia in
the country. During this process it was discovered that
the new material was in fact of the little known species P.
quadrifaria Dinter, which had been considered a synonym of P. lucilioides DC. by subsequent authors
(Merxmüller 1955, 1967).
Pteronia is a mainly southern African genus comprising about 70 species. Within the tribe Astereae it is
presently placed in the subtribe Solidagininae O. Hoffm.
(which consists mostly of North American genera) and
in turn into the Engleria group (Bremer 1994) of that
subtribe. Pteronia is considered to be isolated among the
African Compositae (Bremer 1994) and most closely
related to Engleria O. Hoffm., which, however, has
radiate capitula compared to the discoid capitula of
Pteronia. Morphologically there exists similarity with
Chrysocoma L. and other African genera of the Amellus
group in the subtribe Asterinae (Bremer 1994). Charac-
ters that are rare in the Astereae are found in Pteronia,
like a spiny habit, opposite and succulent leaves and
beaked achenes (Bremer 1994). Bremer (1994) concluded that the placement of Pteronia in the subtribe
Solidagininae must be considered very uncertain, a
point of view discussed below. Pending a revision of the
entire genus, its subtribal affiliation cannot be completely ascertained (Bremer 1994). The most recent comprehensive treatment (Hutchinson & Phillips 1917) is,
however, over 90 years old. In Namibia, the genus was
last revised by Merxmüller in 1967. Since then, one
additional species (P. anisata B. Nord.) has been
recorded for Namibia (Merxmüller & Roessler 1984).
Hutchinson & Phillips’s (1917) revision included the 63
species accepted by de Candolle (1836) that were
grouped in three sections (sect. Scepinia (Neck. ex
Cass.) DC., sect. Pachyderis (Cass.) DC., sect.
Pterophorus (Vaill. ex Adans.) DC.). However, they
regarded the difference between Scepinia and
Pachyderis as indistinct and the distinguishing character of Pterophorus (a monospecific section according to Harvey 1865) as “trifling”. The 61 species
that they accepted were then divided into four new
sections based mainly on leaf indumentum:
I. Incanae — leaves with woolly, whitish indumentum
II. Papillatae — entire leaf surface papillous or scabrid
III. Ciliatae — leaves ciliate mostly on margins or keels
but otherwise glabrous
IV. Glabratae — leaves entirely glabrous and mostly fleshy
Accepted for publication 22 January 2014.
1
Millennium Seed Bank Partnership, National Botanical Research Institute, Windhoek, Namibia. email: hertak@nbri.org.na.
2
Millennium Seed Bank Partnership, Seed Conservation Department, Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, Wakehurst Place, Ardingly, nr Haywards Heath, West
Sussex, RH17 6TN, UK. e-mail: m.vanslageren@kew.org
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 2 of 44
Merxmüller (1952) noted that this division is not at all
consistent and that, for instance, Pteronia divaricata Less.
and P. lucilioides DC., which both were classified by
Hutchinson & Phillips as belonging to sect. Papillatae,
differ very much in the degree to which the leaves are
papillate. On the other hand, P. unguiculata S. Moore and
P. mucronata DC., which belong to sect. Glabratae and sect.
Ciliatae respectively, are related more closely than would
be expected from them being in different sections.
(It should be noted that as section Ciliatae included
the type of the genus, P. camphorata (L.) L., this
name was not validly published and should be
section Pteronia.) In view of this we have not further
considered these sections.
Materials and Methods
Herbarium specimens at K, NBG, SAM and WIND and
high resolution images of herbarium specimens at the
herbaria of B, BM, BOL, G, G-DC, GH, GRA, HAL, HBG,
K, KW, LD, M, NBG, NY, P, PRE, S, SAM, TUB, W
(including W-Rchb.), Z were studied. Except for type
specimens, these were Namibian specimens only because this study was not intended to be a full revision of
the genus but merely a summary of what is known about
Pteronia in Namibia. Species descriptions and the key
were compiled from a combination of published information and characters observed on Namibian herbarium specimens. Global distributions were obtained from
literature and online databases, mainly the African Plant
Database (http://www.ville-ge.ch/musinfo/bd/cjb/
africa/index.php?langue=an). The habitat of species
was derived from a summary of Namibian specimen
label information only. Altitude ranges therefore are
only those stated in the collection information and relate
to Namibia only. Where there is only one altitude, either
only one specimen contained altitude information or
several specimens had exactly the same altitude. Similarly, phenology of species is that derived from Namibian
specimens only. This obviously has limitations as the
number of specimens with the required information
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
may be very few. The information given should not be
seen as applicable to the species in their entire
distribution range. Conservation status was assessed
using Guidelines for Using the IUCN Red List Categories and
Criteria. Version 10 (IUCN 2013). Since mainly Namibian
specimens were examined and no fieldwork was done in
other countries besides Namibia, the assessments were
made for Namibia only (for the endemic species this is
obviously a global assessment). Where available, South
African assessments were obtained from literature and
online databases (SANBI 2011).
Pteronia L. (Linnaeus 1763b: 1176; 1764: 414); de
Candolle (1836: 356); Harvey in Harvey & Sonder
(1865: 95); Hutchinson & Phillips (1917: 278);
Merxmüller (1967: 150); Bremer (1994: 408). Type:
Pteronia camphorata (L.) L.
Shrubs with opposite, alternate or fascicled leaves, these
glabrous, papillate, glandular or with conspicuous bristles
and entire margins. Capitula solitary or corymbose, homogamous, discoid. Receptacle convex, flat or concave, often
honeycombed, fimbriate, setate or lacerate. Phyllaries
multiseriate, gradate, imbricate; apex often mucronate;
margins often membranous. Florets hermaphrodite; corollas
tubular, actinomorphic, 5-lobed, yellow or white. Stamens 5.
Anthers more or less obtuse, rarely acute, at base. Style with
two deltoid-tipped, flattened branches bearing short to
long stigmatic papillae near apex. Achenes obconical,
obovoid or turbinate, sometimes flattened or contracted
into a neck apically, glabrous, glandular or variously hairy;
carpopodium a slightly asymmetrical ring with a narrow
interruption. Pappus of unequal, scabrid to barbellate setae,
sometimes basally connate or scale-like and broadened.
Diagnostic characters of Pteronia are discoid capitula
with multiseriate, gradate and densely imbricate phyllaries,
bi- or multiseriate pappus consisting of bristles only (some
bristles may be scale-like broadened at the base), achenes
that are sometimes narrowed into an apical neck and
mostly opposite leaves (Bremer 1994; Herman et al. 2000).
Updated key to Pteronia in Namibia
1. Leaves with dense, white to grey, felty indumentum. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
Leaves glabrous, papillose, glandular, bristly, ciliate or pectinate but never felty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
2. Phyllaries acute, midrib broader towards apex but never mucronate; pappus yellowish-brown. . . 9. P. glauca
Phyllaries mucronate; pappus maroon-purple or yellow . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
3. Pappus maroon-purple; phyllaries reddish-purple. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .7. P. eenii
Pappus yellow; phyllaries yellow. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. P. acuta
4. Leaves, at least those at branch tips surrounding capitula, ciliate to pectinate or bristly, papillose or glandular
on surface. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
Leaves glabrous to minutely puberulous or minutely papillate, may appear warty when dried. . . . . . . . . . .13
5. Leaf margins ciliate-pectinate or bristly, leaf surface glabrous, bristly or minutely papillose, leaves alternate,
alternate to almost opposite, opposite or decussate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
9488, Page 3 of 44
Leaf margins not ciliate-pectinate or bristly, leaf surface papillose, with short bristles or glandular, leaves
opposite . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .10
Only leaves at branch tips surrounding capitula, with ciliate margins, others glabrous to glabrescent . .17. P. pomonae
All leaf margins ciliate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
Capitula 20 × 7 mm at most, narrowly cylindrical, apex of phyllaries truncate. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
Capitula to 35 × 25 mm, ovoid-obconical, apex of phyllaries rounded or acute. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
Pappus yellowish; apex of phyllaries truncate, mucronulate, not reflexed; leaves opposite, connate at base,
clustered along branches; achenes densely villous . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13. P. mucronata
Pappus maroon-purple; apex of phyllaries reflexed, margins undulate; leaves sessile, imbricate-decussate,
mostly only towards branch tips, lower leaves soon dehiscent; achenes glandular . . . . . . . . 18. P. quadrifaria
Leaves alternate, margins white bristly, to 20 × 5 mm; phyllaries coriaceous, apex rounded; achenes
glandular . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14. P. onobromoides
Leaves opposite, margins and keel ciliate, 8 – 10 × 4 mm; phyllaries membranous, apex acute; achenes
glabrous or with a few hairs on ribs. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24. P. viscosa
Phyllaries yellowish, without membranous margin; capitula acute in bud . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .12. P. lucilioides
Phyllaries with conspicuous membranous margin; capitula not markedly acute in bud . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .11
Capitula ovoid-campanulate, 15 – 20 × 6 – 10 mm; phyllaries ovate to orbicular; leaves sessile, oblong to narrowly
ovate, apex rounded, 5 – 15 × 4 mm . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10. P. inflexa
Capitula cylindrical, 15 × 3 – 9 mm; phyllaries lanceolate-oblong, linear-oblong, the outer sometimes ovate;
leaves narrowing into a short petiole, obovate, spathulate or orbicular, 10 – 25 × 8 – 15 mm . . . . . . . . . . .12
Capitula solitary on branch tips, 10 – 12-flowered . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16. P. polygalifolia
Capitula in terminal corymbs, each 5-flowered . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. P. divaricata
Leaves alternate (may be almost opposite in P. acuminata). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .14
Leaves opposite . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .18
Phyllaries rounded, ciliate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. P. ciliata
Phyllaries tapering, acute, not ciliate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .15
Phyllaries with thickened, glandular midrib; apex somewhat acute, reflexed; margins narrow,
white. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19. P. rangei
Phyllaries without thickened midrib but tapering into a sharp, long tip or if a shorter tip, then margins broad
membranous . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .16
Phyllaries broadly lanceolate; midrib narrow, brown; remainder of phyllaries transparent, membranous; apex
acute . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20. P. scariosa
Phyllaries lanceolate; broad opaque centre brownish; margins membranous, transparent . . . . . . . . . . . . . .17
Leaves to 7 × 1.5 mm, oblong to narrowly obovate, narrowed into base, apex rounded, glabrous; phyllaries
glabrous, lanceolate, 2 – 3 mm long acuminate, keeled; inner phyllaries to 2.5 mm broad; margins
membranous; young branches white . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. P. leucoclada
Leaves to 20 × 8 mm, ovate-obovate to oblanceolate, sessile or short petiolate, apex acute; phyllaries silvery-grey
puberulous, linear to lanceolate, apex acutely mucronate; inner phyllaries to 2 mm broad; margins
membranous; young branches white, grey or brown . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .1. P. acuminata
More than one capitulum at branch tips . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .15. P. paniculata
Capitula solitary at branch tips . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .19
Opposite leaves connate at base but not sheathing, the connecting part persistent when leaves dehisce, forming rows
of spinules on branches . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .22. P. spinulosa
Leaves without clear connecting part and therefore without spinules on branches (leaf bases of P. sordida may
be slightly fused, but do no form spinules after dehiscence) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .20
Capitula cylindrical, to 8 mm in diam.; phyllaries yellowish . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .21
Capitula broadly ovoid or obconical, to 15 mm in diam.; phyllaries brownish or dark green. . . . . . . . . . . .23
Phyllaries broadest at apex, somewhat constricted below apex, mucronate, bright yellow; apex truncate, often
somewhat emarginate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .23. P. unguiculata
Phyllaries obovate-roundish, mucronulate or without mucro . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .22
Phyllaries obovate to linear-oblong, very shortly mucronate, pale yellow; margins lacerate . . 5. P. cylindracea
Phyllaries ovate, not mucronate, green with dark brown, glandular, longitudinal lines; margins
hyaline . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. P. anisata
Phyllaries broadly ovate to almost circular; apex rounded; margins narrow membranous all around . . . 8. P. glabrata
Phyllaries oblong-oblanceolate; apex acute to obtuse; margins membranous laterally only . . . .21. P. sordida
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 4 of 44
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
Synopsis of Namibian species
1. Pteronia acuminata DC. (de Candolle 1836: 361);
Harvey in Harvey & Sonder (1865: 105); Hutchinson &
Phillips (1917: 315); Merxmüller (1967: 154);
Merxmüller & Roessler (1984: 89); Herman (2003:
276). Type: South Africa, Northern Cape Prov.,
between Zack and Gariep rivers, 11 Sept. 1811, Burchell
1587 (holotype G-DC!; isotypes GH-00011510!, K000273485!, PRE).
Dicoma ramosissima Klatt (1896: 843); Dinter (1921:
186). Syntypes: Namibia, Aob bei Keetmanshoop,
1892, Fleck 116 (GH-00006368 (fragment), Z000003295!); Namibia, Aob bei Keetmanshoop,
1891, Fenchel 51 (GH-00006368 (fragment), Z000003294!).
Pteronia carnosa Muschl. (Muschler 1911a: 97),
nom. illegit., non P. carnosa Muschl. (Muschler
1911a: 95). Type: Namibia, Bezirk des Damaralandes,
Berseba, Schultze 406 (lectotype K-000273487!, selected here).
Pteronia feddeana Muschl. (Muschler 1911b: 384,
“Feddeana”), Range (1935: 275, “Feddeana”), nom.
nov. for P. carnosa Muschl. (1911a: 97). Type: as for
Pteronia carnosa Muschl. (1911a: 97).
Shrub, 30 – 80 cm high, to 100 cm in diam. Stems
terete, glabrous, brittle, bark white, grey to pale
brown. Leaves alternate to almost opposite, somewhat
succulent, glaucous, glabrous, flat, ovate-obovate to
oblanceolate, 10 – 20 × 5 – 8 mm; apex acute,
mucronate; base cuneate, sessile or short petiolate.
Capitula solitary, terminal, elongate-ovoid, to 25 mm
long; apex pointed in bud. Receptacle slightly convex,
honeycombed, to 4 mm in diam. Phyllaries
multiseriate, gradate, outer broadly lanceolate, to 4 ×
2 mm, inner linear to narrowly lanceolate, to 20 × 2
mm, silvery-grey puberulous; apex acutely mucronate;
margins membranous. Florets 10 – 12; corollas to 2 mm
long, yellow; lobes lanceolate, subacute. Achenes compressed, densely appressed villous, to 5 mm long.
Pappus to 15 mm long, golden to straw-coloured.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Botswana, Namibia, South Africa.
Map 1.
1
NAMIBIA. Hardap Region,
Maltahöhe Distr.: Grootfonteiner Fläche, 29 Sept.
1959, Giess 2286 (PRE, WIND!); 3 km from
Maltahöhe on road to Helmeringhausen, on road
verge, 19 Oct. 1987, Kolberg & Maggs HK94 (PRE,
WIND!); Farm Grootfontein (Lisbon) MAL 9, 5 Sept.
1972, Merxmüller & Giess 28243 (M, PRE, WIND!);
Farm Lisbon MAL 9, 8 April 1980, Müller 1274
(WIND!); Farm Naudaus/Duwisib MAL 76/84, 20
SPECIMENS EXAMINED.
1
With Specimens Examined we list inspected sheets from
herbaria (marked with “!”) and other herbaria which are
known to hold a duplicate specimen.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
Map 1. Known distribution of Pteronia acuminata in Namibia.
May 1956, Volk 12557 (WIND!); Mariental Distr.:
Farm Haribes GIB 18/19, 30 May 1963, Leippert 4734
(WIND!); Torro plain at station Ebenerde, 10 Sept.
1963, Merxmüller; Giess 3602 (M, PRE, WIND!); Karas
Region, Bethanie Distr.: N of Helmeringhausen, 7
Sept. 2002, Burke 02074 (WIND!); Farm Goais 21 km
(13.3 miles) S of Helmeringhausen, 19 May 1965, Giess
8811 (PRE, WIND!); Farm Huns, BET 106, 12 Aug.
1976, Giess 14601 (PRE, WIND!); Karasburg Distr.:
Klein Karas, 7 Aug. 1923, Dinter 4862 (SAM, Z!); Farm
Windkraal WAR 34, 20 May 1963, Giess, Volk & Bleissner
7120 (WIND!); Farm Vrede, S of house, 10 Sept. 2005,
Kolberg & Tholkes HK1688 (K!, WIND!); Farm
Mooiplaats WAR 97, 6 Oct. 1977, Merxmüller & Giess
32521 (M, PRE, WIND!); Klein Karas, April 1890,
Schäfer 222 (K!); Farm Rishon, Karasberge,
Graberberg. Near Post Office tower, 23 June 1989,
Van Wyk 8696 (PRE, WIND!); Keetmanshoop Distr.: 7
miles W of Aroab on road to Keetmanshoop, 3 May
1955, De Winter 3381 (PRE, WIND!); Aob bei
Keetmanshoop, 1891, Fenchel 51 (Dicoma ramosissima
syntype GH-00006368 (fragment), Z-000003294!); Aob
bei Keetmanshoop, 1892, Fleck 116 (Dicoma ramosissima
syntype GH-00006368 (fragment), Z-000003295!);
Berseba Reservat KEE 170, 13 May 1963, Giess, Volk
& Bleissner 6864 (WIND!); Berseba, Aug. 1905, Schultze
406 (P. feddeana lectotype K-000273487!); Farm
Springboktrek South 223, on S end of pan N of
homestead, 12 Feb. 1997, Strohbach, Kubirske &
Sheuyange 2786 (WIND!); Farm Springboktrek South
223, on S end of pan N of homestead, 18 Feb. 1998,
Strohbach 3650 (WIND!); Lüderitz Distr.: State land,
Nuobrivier, Huns Mts, S of Farm Uitsig LU 82, 9 June
1976, Giess & Müller 14327 (WIND!); State land, 3 km
S of border of Farm Uitsig, 25 Sept. 1976, Giess &
Wendt 14702 (WIND!); Aus – Rosh Pinah road in
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
washes near Aus Marble turnoff, 29 Sept. 2004,
Mannheimer, Maggs-Kölling & Loots CM2656 (WIND!).
SOUTH AFRICA. Northern Cape Prov., Carnarvon Distr.:
at Karel Kriegers grave, between the Karmee Bergen
[Kareeberge] and Buffels Bout, between Zack and
Gariep rivers, 11 Sept. 1811, Burchell 1587 (P.
acuminata holotype G-DC!; isotypes GH-00011510, K00273485!, PRE).
HABITAT. Mostly on calcareous soil in dwarf shrub
savanna; altitude c. 950 m; summer or summer-winter
transition rainfall areas of south-central and southeastern Namibia (Map 1).
CONSERVATION STATUS. In Namibia this species does
not qualify for any of the threatened categories
according to the five IUCN criteria. No threats to
populations were identified and both the estimated
Extent Of Occurrence (EOO) and Area Of Occupancy
(AOO) of this fairly widespread species are well above
the maxima for the threatened categories (IUCN
2001, 2013). The Namibian status therefore is Least
Concern (LC). The South African threat status is cited
as LC (SANBI 2011).
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: April to October. Fruiting:
August to February.
NOTES. Muschler (1911a) caused some confusion by
publishing two species under the name Pteronia
carnosa, one of which (1911a: 97) he corrected in the
same year to P. feddeana Muschl. (Muschler 1911b).
Hutchinson & Phillips (1917) considered this taxon to
be conspecific with P. acuminata, which was followed
by more recent authors (Merxmüller 1952, 1967;
Herman 2003), an opinion with which we agree. The
second P. carnosa (Muschler 1911a: 95), an illegitimate
name, is now considered a synonym of P. glabrata L. f.
(q.v.). In his description of P. carnosa Muschler (1911a:
97) cited Schultze 406 and von Trotha 129. Schultze 406
was traced in K, but the von Trotha specimen was not
found in any herbarium where it was likely to be
housed. Muschler worked from B and the specimen
was most likely preserved there and destroyed during
World War II. Schultze 406 at K is therefore selected as
the lectotype.
9488, Page 5 of 44
campanulate-obconic, 10 – 15 × 10 mm, surrounded at
its base by short leaves; apex rounded in bud. Phyllaries
multiseriate, gradate, outer linear lanceolate, to 5 mm
long, inner linear-oblong, to 10 mm long, yellow,
woolly pubescent on outside; apex acute, mucronate;
margins very narrow, membranous. Florets c. 14; corollas
to 6 mm long, pubescent on outside, yellow; lobes
linear, subacute; tube ribbed at base. Achenes obconic,
long sericeous, c. 3 mm long. Pappus setae barbellate,
to 7 mm long, yellow to straw-coloured.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Namibia, South Africa. Map 2.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Hardap Region,
Maltahöhe Distr.: Naukluft plateau, 6 July 1993,
Bridgeford 142 (WIND!); Naukluft, Kapokvlakte, on
plateau, Nov. 1995, Bridgeford 95360 (WIND!);
Naukluft Plateau, Kapokvlakte, March 1994, Günster
9452 (WIND!); Farm Zaris MAL 103, at peak of pass, 4
Sept. 1972, Merxmüller & Giess 28202 (M, WIND!);
Farm Rooiberg-Süd, 1935, Steyn 9960 (WIND!); Farm
Wereldend 115, Helmeringhausen, 17 May 1956, Volk
12798 (WIND!); Karas Region, Bethanie Distr.: Farm
Aruab 23, plains on S part, April 1998, Miller MIL1/
065 (WIND!); Lüderitz Distr.: Farm Witpütz Nord LU
22, 1 km E of police station, 30 Sept. 1975, Giess 13779
(WIND!); State land 3 km S of border to Farm Uitsig,
26 Sept. 1976, Giess & Wendt 14706 (WIND!); Farm
Plateau LU 38, not far from the farmhouse, Aus, 8
Sept. 1963, Kräusel & Wiss 2016 (WIND!); Chamis,
Sept. 1905, Schultze 433 (lectotype K-00273412!).
HABITAT. Rocky areas in desert-dwarf shrub savanna
transition zone; c. 1600 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. In Namibia this species is
evaluated LC (IUCN 2001, 2013) as no threats to
populations could be identified and the estimated EOO
and AOO are above those that would qualify it for the
2. Pteronia acuta Muschl. (Muschler 1911a: 99); Hutchinson & Phillips (1917: 286); Dinter (1926: 131); Range
(1935: 275); Merxmüller (1967: 154); Merxmüller &
Roessler (1984: 89); Herman (2003: 276). Type: Namibia, Bezirk des Damaralandes, Chamis, Sept. 1905, Schultze
433 (lectotype K-00273412!, selected here).
Shrub, 15 – 50 cm high, to 30 cm in diam. Stems
appressed pubescent, pale grey, Leaves opposite,
usually clustered along stems, pale grey, densely felty
to woolly pubescent, linear to linear-lanceolate,
trigonous, 4 – 10 × 1 – 1.5 mm; apex acute to
subobtuse; connate at base. Capitula solitary, terminal,
Map 2. Known distribution of Pteronia acuta in Namibia.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 6 of 44
threatened categories. The South African threat status is
recorded as Least Concern (LC) (SANBI 2011).
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: March to September. Fruiting:
July to November.
NOTES. In Namibia the species occurs along the southwestern escarpment between the coastal Namib desert
and the inland plateau (Map 2) and prefers altitudes
above 1500 m. When capitula are immature and the
yellowish pappus is not visible, this species could be
mistaken for Pteronia eenii but the known distributions of
these species do not overlap (compare Maps 2 and 7).
In his description Muschler (1911a: 100) cited Schultze
433 and von Trotha 147a, both with exactly the same
locality and date. Schultze 433 could be traced in K, but von
Trotha 147a was not found in any herbarium where it was
likely to be housed. As Muschler worked from B any
original specimen was most likely destroyed during World
War II. Schultze 433 at K is thus selected as the lectotype.
3. Pteronia anisata B. Nord. (Nordenstam 1971: 10);
Roessler & Merxmüller (1982: 192); Merxmüller &
Roessler (1984: 89); Herman (2003: 276). Type: South
Africa, Northern Cape Prov., Namaqualand Div.,
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
Richtersveld, Cornell's Kop, N slopes, 31 Oct. 1962,
Nordenstam 1694 (holotype S-G-5140!; isotypes M0104529!, PRE, SAM).
Aromatic shrub, to 40 cm high. Stems brown when young,
dark grey when older. Leaves opposite, clustered along
stems, succulent, green with brown resin dots, surface
minutely papillate, terete to trigonous to somewhat
flattened, to 20 × 1.5 mm, base somewhat clasping with
tuft of hairs in axil. Capitula solitary, terminal, cylindrical,
to 10 × 6 mm; apex rounded in bud. Receptacle with lobed
and fringed scales. Phyllaries 3 – 4-seriate, ovate to
oblong, outer 3 × 1.5 mm, inner 10 × 4 mm, green with
dark, resinous striations; apex obtuse; margins membranous white. Florets to 8; corollas 7 – 7.5 mm long, yellow;
lobes triangular with few resin glands on outside; tube
puberulous at base. Achenes obovoid with constricted
apical neck, densely off-white sericeous, 3 – 4 × 2 mm.
Pappus of numerous setae united into an annulus at base,
5 – 6 mm long, pale red-brown. Fig. 1.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Namibia, South Africa. Map 3.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Karas Region, Lüderitz
Distr.: Lorelei, fountain with "waterfall" in dune area
Fig. 1. Pteronia anisata showing the bead-like veins on the phyllaries.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
PHOTO: H. KOLBERG.
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
9488, Page 7 of 44
recorded in southern Namibia in 1977, some 170 km
NNW of the type locality. Only 30 years later the
species was found again just north of the Namibian –
South African border (Map 3 & Fig. 1). The known
distribution of Pteronia anisata suggests that it is nearendemic to Namibia and rare.
Map 3. Known distribution of Pteronia anisata in Namibia.
(NE), 12 Oct. 2007, Kolberg & Tholkes HK2381 (K!,
WIND!); Sperrgebiet. Daberas Vley, W of dunes, E of
Schakalsberge, 16 Oct. 2008, Kolberg & Tholkes HK2660
(K!, WIND!); Sperrgebiet, 19 km S of Obib Fountain,
track turns E and leads over hill, 24 Oct. 2008, Kolberg &
Tholkes HK2695 (K!, WIND!); Diamond Area 1, Tsaus
Spinnenberg, Oct. 1977, Wendt 15/3 (M, WIND!). SOUTH
AFRICA. Northern Cape Prov.: Namaqualand Div.,
Richtersveld, Cornell's Kop (near Annisfontein), N
slopes, 31 Oct. 1962, Nordenstam 1694 (holotype S (coll.
S-G-5140)!; isotypes M-0104529!, PRE, SAM).
HABITAT. On blue dolomite or white quartz outcrops in steppe dominated by succulent species;
200 – 450 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. Pteronia anisata occurs in the
protected diamond mining area of Namibia where
human access and activities are strictly controlled and
limited. Mining occurs in very restricted localities and
mostly along the coast, outside the distribution area of
this species. Although the estimated EOO and AOO
would qualify the species as VU under criterion B, the
required two criteria of fragmentation, decline or
fluctuation of populations have not been observed.
Similarly, under criterion D2 P. anisata is known from
fewer than 5 localities but this is not coupled with the
required plausible future threat. The species therefore
is evaluated as LC in Namibia (IUCN 2001, 2013), but
the scarcity of herbarium specimens and information
from recent collections suggests that it is rare in
Namibia.
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: October.
ETYMOLOGY. The specific epithet denotes that the
plant smells of aniseed (Nordenstam 1971).
NOTES. Described in 1971 from the Richtersveld in
South Africa (Nordenstam 1971), Roessler &
Merxmüller (1982) reported that this species was also
4. Pteronia ciliata Thunb. (Thunberg 1800: 144); de
Candolle (1836: 359); Harvey in Harvey & Sonder
(1865: 102); Hutchinson & Phillips (1917: 317);
Merxmüller (1967: 155); Merxmüller & Roessler
(1984: 89); Herman (2003: 277). Type: South Africa,
Western Cape Prov., Cape of Good Hope, Thunberg
s.n. (holotype UPS-THUNB; isotype S-07-7225!).
Pteronia ciliata Thunb. var. [“β”] subtrigona DC. (de
Candolle 1836: 360). Type: South Africa, Western Cape
Prov., Olifantrivier, W. F., Drège s.n. [5664 — see Notes]
(holotype G-DC; isotypes HBG-505132!, P-027011!).
Pteronia ciliata Thunb. var. ecklonis Harv. (Harvey in
Harvey & Sonder 1865: 102, “Ecklonis”). Type: South
Africa, Northern Cape Prov., Namaqualand, Nov.
1837, Ecklon & Zeyher 238 (holotype PRE). — see
Notes.
Pteronia ciliata Thunb. var. thunbergii Harv. (Harvey in
Harvey & Sonder 1865: 102, “Thunbergii”), nom.
illegit. Type: as for P. ciliata.
Pteronia turbinata DC. (de Candolle 1836: 362); Harvey
in Harvey & Sonder (1865: 106). Type: South
Africa, Northern Cape Prov., Gariep, Klein-Namaqualand, Drège s.n. [5665] (holotype G-DC; isotypes
HAL-0110987, HBG-505180!, NY-00232710!, P027281!, P-027282!, P-027283, P-027284!, PRE, WRchb-1889-0278258!, W-0008809!). — see Notes.
Shrub, to 100 cm high. Stems slightly puberulous, pale
grey. Leaves alternate, clustered on stem tips, succulent, glabrous, linear, grooved above, keeled below, to
10 × 1 – 1.5 mm; apex obtuse, base cuneate; pleasant
aroma. Capitula solitary, terminal, ovoid-cylindrical, to
15 – 20 × 5 – 7 mm; apex contracted. Receptacle
concave, fimbriate-honeycombed. Phyllaries 7 – 10seriate, gradate, ovate to linear, to 12 mm long,
straw-coloured; midrib faint; apex obtuse; margins
distinctly ciliate. Florets to 15; corollas to 10 mm long,
glabrous, greenish-yellow; lobes linear-lanceolate,
acute. Achenes obconic, long sericeous, to 3 mm long.
Pappus multiseriate, to 5 mm long, brownish-yellow.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Namibia, South Africa. Map 4.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Karas Region, Lüderitz
Distr.: Diamond Area 1, Klinghardts Mts, 2 Jan. 1996,
Burke 96134 (WIND!); Sperrgebiet. N Klinghardts Mts,
5 Aug. 2001, Klaassen & Bartsch EK484 (WIND!); First
level section above the E foot of Rooiberg
(Sperrgebiet), 4 Sept. 1992, Kubirske, Strohbach & Swart
42 (WIND!); Sperrgebiet. Klinghardts Mts, 11 Sept.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 8 of 44
Map 4. Known distribution of Pteronia ciliata in Namibia.
2005, Kwembeya EKw64 (WIND!); Granite outcrops on
road to Obib, SW of Farm Spitzkop, 1 Sept. 1963,
Merxmüller & Giess 3424 (M, WIND!); W edge of Obib
Mts Hill 3 km N of Obibwasser, 2 Sept. 1977,
Merxmüller & Giess 32382 (M, WIND!); Gabusib, Feb.
1992, Strohbach 73 (WIND!). SOUTH AFRICA. Northern
Cape Prov.: Klein Namaqualand, between Kaus,
Natvoet and Doornpoort [III B 6], 17 Oct. 1830, Drège
s.n.; Namaqualand, Drège s.n. [5665] (P. turbinata
holotype G-DC; isotypes HAL-0110987, HBG-505180!,
NY-00232710!, P-027281!, P-027282!, P-027283, P027284!, PRE, W-Rchb-1889-0278258!, W-0008809!); Namaqualand, Nov. 1837, Ecklon & Zeyher 238 (P. ciliata var.
ecklonis holotype PRE, possible isotype HBG-505133!);
Western Cape Prov.: Ebenezar, on rocky, dry karoo hills
[III E a 4], Nov. 1833, Drège s.n. (K-000273499!);
Olifantrivier, W. F., Drège s.n. [5664] (P. ciliata var.
subtrigona holotype G-DC; isotypes HBG-505132!, P027011!); Cape of Good Hope, Thunberg s.n. (P. ciliata
holotype UPS-THUNB; isotype S-07-7225!).
HABITAT. Rocky slopes in steppe dominated by succulent species; 700 – 800 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. The estimated EOO and AOO
of this species falls below the threshold value for the
VU category, but two of the additional criteria of
population fragmentation, decline or fluctuation
could not be satisfied. Also under criterion D2,
although the number of localities is ≤5, qualifying
for VU, a plausible future threat could not be
established. The Namibian threat status thus is LC
(IUCN 2001, 2013). Present data, however, suggest
that the species is rare in Namibia. The South African
threat status is LC (SANBI 2011).
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: February to September.
Fruiting: August.
VERNACULAR NAME. Biltongbos (Afrikaans, South
Africa).
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
NOTES. Only a few collections have been made in
Namibia (and all of these since 1963) but Pteronia
ciliata is more widespread in South Africa.
The locality cited with the holotype (as well as in de
Candolle’s Prodromus) of Pteronia ciliata var. subtrigona is
only “Olifantrivier”, a river that runs through the
Western Cape Province in South Africa. Similar to P.
latisquama (a synonym of the accepted P. glauca, see
below) it is problematic to ascertain which collections
are possibly isotypes of the varietal name. Critical
evaluation includes P-027011, as it carries not only
“5664” on the label, but has another small label
attached, which we believe may well present locality
details, date, and coding in Drège’s handwriting. It
reads (in our annotated version): “/11 33 [as in:
November 1833] [unreadable location name] bei
Ebenezar [which is on the Olifant River], — 300 [as
in: meters altitude] (III, E, a)”. (The coding system of
III, E, a, etc. is explained below in the notes at P.
glauca.). More locality details are provided by, for
example HBG-505132 (annotated with “Pteronia ciliata
β. DC.” and considered an isotype): “Ebenezar, auf
steinigen, trockenen (karrooartigen) Hügeln” with the
locality code “III E a 4” added. Other specimens marked
similarly “5664” but in clearly different handwriting are
P-027010 and P-027013. A similar problem is a possible
isotype (HBG-505133) of P. ciliata var. ecklonis: this is
reportedly an Ecklon & Zeyher collection, but does not
show no. 238 and while considered an (iso-) type this is
with a question mark.
The locality cited for the type of Pteronia turbinata is
the one recorded on the holotype, but more precise
locations are found on some of the isotypes, such as
“zwischen Kaus, Natvoet und Doornpoort [III B 6]”,
Drège s.n. (HAL-0110987, HBG-505180, W-0008809);
but “17 / 10 30 (= 17 Oct. 1830), Kaus” (in what looks
like Drège’s handwriting) and the number 5665 are on
isotype P-027281. The date mentioned on K-00273497
is 1837, which could refer to a collection or herbarium
dispatch or receipt date. This specimen, as well as K00273498 does not refer to the number “5665” and
both are not considered to be isotypes.
It should be noted that here and elsewhere for taxa
described in the Prodromus by Auguste Pyramus de
Candolle, we follow the information provided to us by
Dr Fernand Jacquemoud in Geneva who kindly
inspected the type material.
5. Pteronia cylindracea DC. (de Candolle 1836: 363);
Harvey in Harvey & Sonder (1865: 106); Hutchinson &
Phillips (1917: 313); Dinter (1926: 132); Range (1935:
275); Merxmüller (1967: 155); Merxmüller & Roessler
(1984: 89); Herman (2003: 277). Type: South Africa,
Northern Cape Prov., at Buffels Bout, Carnarvon Div.,
12 Sept. 1811, Burchell 1603 (holotype G-DC; isotypes
K-00273480!, P-027025!, PRE).
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
Shrub to 40 cm high. Stems glabrous, older branches
very woody, bark grey. Leaves opposite, mostly clustered along stems, glabrous, linear, flat or grooved
above, to 10 × 1 mm; apex hooked; base sometimes
eared and clasping stem but not connate. Capitula
solitary, terminal, cylindrical, 20 – 25 × 6 mm; apex
acute. Phyllaries multiseriate, gradate, obovate to
linear-oblong, 5 – 15 × 4 mm; pale, matte yellow,
chaffy-membranous; apex obtuse, mucronulate; margins lacerate. Florets c. 5; corollas to 15 mm long,
exserted up to 8 mm from phyllaries, yellow; lobes
linear lanceolate, subacute; tube widening in upper
half. Achenes narrowly obconic, long sericeous and
densely sessile glandular, c. 5 mm long. Pappus
multiseriate, to 10 mm long, straw-coloured.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Botswana, Namibia, South Africa.
Map 5.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Khomas Region, Windhoek Distr.: Khomas Hochland, 14 May 2000, Burke
00090 (WIND!); Farm Harris (22), 32 km (20 miles)
SW of Windhoek, 2 March 1955, De Winter 2546
(WIND!); Farm Mahonda WIN 39, 12 July 1963, Giess
7628 (WIND!); Farm Bergland, 12 Aug. 1963,
Merxmüller & Giess 3593 (M, PRE, WIND!); Verdwaal
(REH 41), 29 Aug. 1972, Merxmüller & Giess 28087 (M,
PRE, WIND!); Farm Naos, 1 Jan. 1953, Schwerdtfeger
4227 (WIND!); Avis, Windhoek, 6 May 1964, Seydel
4016 (WIND!); Avis, the mountain parallel with the
Avis R., at power lines, 26 July 1966, Seydel 4432
(WIND!); Farm Haris, on S part of pan, 18 April
2000, Strohbach BS5102 (WIND!); Farm Lichtenstein
Süd, dissected plain towards SW corner, 29 April 2002,
Strohbach BS5586 (WIND!); Grazing plots. Neudam
Experimental Farm, 23 June 1959, Van Vuuren 595
(PRE, WIND!); Omaheke Region, Gobabis Distr.:
Map 5. Known distribution of Pteronia cylindracea in Namibia.
9488, Page 9 of 44
Farm Sturmfeld, Steinhausen, 19 June 1958,
Schwerdtfeger 4081 (WIND!); Farm Sturmfeld GO 252,
Steinhausen, 14 July 1962, Toelken 156 (WIND!);
Otjinene Distr.: among rocks and stones on banks of
Eiseb omuramba, 54 miles from Gam, on way to
Windhoek, 31 Aug. 1955, Story 5340 (PRE, WIND!);
Otjozondjupa Region, Okahandja Distr.: Farm Osema
OK 63, 25 June 1965, Giess 9006 (WIND!). SOUTH
AFRICA. Northern Cape Prov.: at Buffels Bout,
Carnarvon Div., 12 Sept. 1811, Burchell 1603 (holotype
G-DC; isotypes K-00273480!, P-027025!, PRE).
HABITAT. Plains, slopes, dry river banks in high altitude
shrubland and woodland on Kalahari sands; 1800 –
2100 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. This relatively widespread
species has an estimated EOO and AOO well above
the thresholds for the threatened categories. No small
or restricted populations or decline in population size
could be identified to satisfy any of the five criteria
according to IUCN (2013). The Namibian conservation status is therefore LC (IUCN 2001). SANBI (2011)
lists the South African threat status as LC.
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: January to August. Fruiting:
July to December.
NOTES. It is very difficult to separate this species from the
closely related Pteronia unguiculata, and Merxmüller
(1967) remarked that there is an overlap in the phyllary
characters whereas it is these same characters that are
used to separate these species. The specimens at WIND
could mainly be separated on a phytogeographical basis:
P. cylindracea occurs in Kalahari sand in the north and
east of the country while P. unguiculata is found on rocky,
mountainous terrain at higher altitudes in the south-west
and west of Namibia. In general, capitula of P.
unguiculata are smaller and obtuse in bud, while those
of P. cylindracea are acute; the phyllaries of P. unguiculata
are shiny, bright yellow while those of P. cylindracea are a
matte, pale yellow. More material is needed from the
north-east of Namibia and neighbouring areas in
Botswana and South Africa to arrive at a more definite
conclusion on the relationship between these two
species, taking it outside the scope of this study.
6. Pteronia divaricata Less. (Lessing 1832: 196); de
Candolle (1836: 357); Harvey in Harvey & Sonder
(1865: 99); Hutchinson & Phillips (1917: 296);
Merxmüller (1967: 155); Merxmüller & Roessler
(1984: 89); Herman (2003: 277). Type: South Africa,
Western Cape Prov., Cape of Good Hope, s.coll. s.n.
(lectotype LINN 982.1!, selected by Lowrey in Jarvis &
Turland (1998: 358) for Chrysocoma oppositifolia).
Eupatorium divaricatum P. J. Bergius (1767: 229);
Thunberg (1800: 142), nom. illegit. — see Notes.
Chrysocoma oppositifolia L. (Linnaeus 1760: 18, 1763a:
97, 1763b: 1177), non P. oppositifolia L. Type: as for
P. divaricata — see Notes.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 10 of 44
Shrub to 150 cm high. Stems puberulous, tan to grey.
Leaves opposite, grey-green, surface puberulous-papillate and glandular, flat, obovate to orbicular, 25 × 15
mm; apex subacute to obtuse; base narrowed into a
short petiole; aromatic. Capitula in terminal corymbs,
turbinate, 15 × 3 – 4 mm; apex acute in bud. Phyllaries
multiseriate, outer broadly ovate, 2.5 mm long, inner
linear-oblong, 8 mm long, green to yellow, glabrous;
apex obtuse or subacute; margins membranous. Florets
c. 5, sweetish smell; corollas 10 – 12 mm long, white to
cream; lobes linear-lanceolate, acute; tube gradually
widening, ribbed and pubescent below middle. Achenes
obovoid, compressed, sparingly pubescent, densely
glandular, c. 5 mm long. Pappus multiseriate, setae
connate at base, barbellate, 8 – 10 mm long, whitish or
with reddish tint.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Namibia, South Africa. Map 6.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Karas Region, Lüderitz
Distr.: S of Lüderitz. Diamond Area No. 1. Mountain
slopes E of Aurus Peak in Aurus Mts, 11 Aug. 2001,
Burgoyne 8431b (PRE, WIND!); Rooiberg, Sperrgebiet,
28 Sept. 1996, Burke 96231 (WIND!); About 34 km (21
miles) N of Lorelei Copper Mine on the road to
Witputz, 15 Sept. 1958, De Winter & Giess 6408 (PRE,
WIND!); Farm Namuskluft LU 88, 8 km E of Rosh
Pinah, 13 Aug. 1976, Giess 14614 (PRE, WIND!); Ai-Ais
conservation area, McMillan's Pass, 2 km SE of summit
of pass along track, 12 Oct. 2005, Kolberg & Tholkes
HK1697 (K!, WIND!); Namuskluft LU 88, 13 Sept.
1963, Kräusel & Wiss 2071 (WIND!); 35 km N of Rosh
Pinah (road to Aus), 2 – 4 km W of road, 29 Oct. 1983,
Leuenberger, Raus & Schiers 3248 (WIND!); Base of
Rooiberg, 29 Sept. 1996, Mannheimer & Mannheimer
420 (WIND!); Aurus basin, 10 Aug. 2001, Mannheimer
CM1558 (WIND!); Namuskluft, hill behind hall, 11
Map 6. Known distribution of Pteronia divaricata in Namibia.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
Sept. 2002, Mannheimer CM2256 (WIND!); Farm
Witputz, 26 Aug. 1963, Merxmüller & Giess 3196 (M,
PRE, WIND); Namuskluft LUS 88, 9.5 km E of Rosh
Pinah, 18 Sept. 1972, Merxmüller & Giess 28533 (M,
PRE, WIND!); Farm Zebrafontein LUS 87, 2 April
1972, Merxmüller & Giess 28783 (M, WIND!); Aurus
Mts, quartz koppie 7 km N of the mountains, 20 Sept.
1977, Merxmüller & Giess 32189 (M, PRE, WIND!);
Farm Zebrafontein, 22 Sept. 1981, Müller & Horn 1564
(WIND!); Sperrgebiet, Aurus Mts, main complex
around the beacon, 6 Sept. 1992, Oliver 10148
(WIND!); Numaeis, S of Witputz, Sept. 1957, Rusch
4678 (WIND!); Sperrgebiet, N end of Aurus Mts on W
side, 8 Aug. 2001, Smook 11255 (PRE, WIND!);
Sperrgebiet, N end of Aurus Mts on W side, 8 Aug.
2001, Smook 11263 (PRE, WIND!); Sperrgebiet, SE side
of Aurus Mts just below the highest peak, 11 Aug.
2001, Smook 11341 (PRE, WIND!); Rooiberg, 30
Sept. 1992, Strohbach 299 (WIND!); Rosh Pinah,
Namuskluft 88, 31 Aug. 1989, Van Wyk 8827 (PRE,
WIND!); Rosh Pinah. Namuskluft 88, 31 Aug. 1989,
Van Wyk 8828 (PRE, WIND!). SOUTH AFRICA. Western Cape Prov.: Groenkloof, Drège s.n. (P-027029!,
PRE); Cape of Good Hope, s.coll., s.n. (lectotype
LINN 982.1!).
HABITAT. Rocky slopes and sandy plains in steppe
dominated by succulent species; 600 – 1000 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. The Namibian distribution of
this species is restricted with an estimated EOO
below the threshold for the VU category under
criterion B1 but two of the additional criteria of
population fragmentation, decline or fluctuation
could not be identified (IUCN 2013). The Namibian threat status therefore is LC (IUCN 2001). The
South African threat status is also recorded as LC
(SANBI 2011).
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: April to November. Fruiting:
August to December.
VERNACULAR NAMES. Geelknopbos, spalkpenbos (Afrikaans, South Africa).
NOTES. This species is restricted to the extreme southwest of Namibia (Map 6), which receives winter
rainfall. It is more common in the Northern and
Western Cape Provinces of South Africa. According to
Merxmüller (1967) Pteronia divaricata is reported to
have yellow florets in South Africa whereas in Namibia
only white to cream florets have been seen.
The type of Pteronia divaricata is the same as that of
the Linnaean Chrysocoma oppositifolia. The latter name
was first mentioned in the thesis of Jacob Printz,
Plantae rariores Africanæ, which appeared in 1760 and
where the Chrysocoma is cited under no. 49 on p. 18.
The thesis is also part of Linnaeus’s Amoenitates
academicæ, vol. 6 (1763a: 97), and this version is cited
as “Amœn. acad. 6. afr. 49” in the second edition of
Species plantarum, vol. 2 (1763b: 1177). Both works by
Linnaeus are cited by Bergius when he renamed the
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
9488, Page 11 of 44
species Eupatorium divaricatum (1767: 229), but such a
complete renaming is superfluous and illegitimate.
Lessing’s recombination into Pteronia using the epithet
divaricata created, however, a legitimate replacement
name (as P. oppositifolia would be blocked by the
earlier Linnaean name); its author citation should
ascribe to Lessing only.
7. Pteronia eenii S. Moore (1902: 325); Hutchinson &
Phillips (1917: 287); Merxmüller (1952: 124; 1967:
155); Merxmüller & Roessler (1984: 89); Herman
(2003: 277). Type: Namibia, Damaraland, 1879, Een
s.n. (holotype BM-000903813!).
Dicoma seitziana Dinter (1921: 186, “Seitziana”). Type:
Namibia, Otjozondjupa Region, Grootfontein Distr.,
Gemsbocklaagte, Aug. 1911, Dinter 3007 (lectotype P00138958!, selected here; isolectotypes four sheets in
SAM: SAM-0071799-1to -4, all “!”) — see Notes.
Pteronia feldtmanniana Dinter ex Merxm. (Merxmüller
1955: 79), nom. nud. — see Notes.
Shrub to 50 cm high and in diam. Stems white to grey
woolly. Leaves opposite, densely grey, woolly-felty,
Fig. 2. Capitulum of Pteronia eenii near Grootfontein.
linear, 8 – 15 × 1 – 1.5 mm; apex obtuse; base slightly
eared and clasping stem. Capitula solitary, terminal,
about half its length enclosed by leaves, obconic, 13 –
15 × 8 mm; apex acute in bud. Receptacle flat. Phyllaries
multiseriate, gradate, lanceolate to linear-lanceolate,
4 – 11 mm long, red-brown, maroon to purple, woolly
outside; apex acute, sharply mucronate; margins
narrowly transparent-maroon membranous. Florets c.
15; corollas 7 mm long, glabrous, yellow; lobes linearlanceolate, subacute, tubes constricted and ribbed at
base. Achenes turbinate, 3.5 mm long, densely appressed white villous. Pappus multiseriate, to 11 mm
long, purple to maroon. Fig. 2.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: endemic to Namibia. Map 7.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Unknown Region and
Distr.: Damaraland, 1879, Een s.n. (P. eenii holotype
BM-000903813!); Khomas Region, Windhoek Distr.:
Windhoek and surroundings, 9 March 1988, Bohlmann
88/ 83 (WIND!); Kunene Region, Opuwo Distr.: 9.5
km NW of Ombombo (former road D3708?), 13 June
2007, Kolberg & Tholkes HK2327 (K!, WIND!); Outjo
Distr.: Farm Westland, cattle post to Elf, 21 Oct. 1998,
Hobohm HOB1 28 (WIND!); Omaheke Region,
PHOTO: H. KOLBERG.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 12 of 44
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
VERNACULAR NAME. |haurus (Khoekhoegowab, Namibia).
USES. Forage.
NOTES. Until recently this Namibian endemic has been
Map 7. Known distribution of Pteronia eenii in Namibia.
Gobabis Distr.: On S banks of Epukiro, Sturmfeld, 20
June 1953, Schwerdtfeger 4115 (WIND!); Otjozondjupa
Region, Grootfontein Distr.: Gemsbocklaagte, Aug.
1911, Dinter 3007 (Dicoma seitziana lectotype P00138958!, isolectotypes SAM-0071799-1 to -4!);
Grootfontein, 11 July 1934, Dinter 7691 (HBG!,
WIND!); Farm Rietfontein GR 344, 26 April 1963,
Giess, Volk & Bleissner 6523 (PRE, WIND!); Farm
Achlam GR 583, on Elefantenberg, 12 Nov. 1976, Giess
14790 (PRE, WIND!); Rietfontein GR 344, 3 km (2
miles) towards Waterberg, 27 April 1963, Kers 356
(WIND!); 6.5 km N of Grootfontein on road to Rundu,
23 June 2008, Kolberg & Tholkes HK2633 (K!, WIND!);
Near Meteor, Grootfontein, 19 July 1965, Leach &
Bayliss 13013 (PRE, WIND!); Farm Nassau, 11 Jan.
1953, Walter & Walter 963 (WIND!); Otjiwarongo
Distr.: Omatjenne Experimental Farm, 1940, Pfeiffer
s.n. (WIND-34113!); Okosongomingo, June 1940, Volk
3062 (WIND!).
HABITAT. Rocky calcrete areas in shrubland or woodland; 1400 – 1700 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. Evaluated by the 1994 IUCN
criteria as Lower Risk — Least Concern (LRlc) by
Craven & Loots (2002). Using more recent criteria
(IUCN 2001) the evaluation is found here to be Least
Concern (LC) since the estimated EOO and AOO are
well above the maxima for the threatened categories
and none of the other criteria A to E are met (IUCN
2013). The possible reduction in population size (see
Notes) would also be below the thresholds for the
threatened categories (at least 30% for VU) resulting
in an evaluation of LC. Since this is a Namibian
endemic species, this is a global conservation status
(IUCN 2001).
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: January to July. Fruiting: June
to November.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
recorded only in the central and north-eastern parts of
the country (Map 7). In 2007 the first author found a
small population of Pteronia eenii in north-western Namibia on calcareous soil typical for the species (Fig. 2). This
disjunct distribution could be explained by either undercollection in the north-central areas of Namibia or by the
species’ preference of calcrete substrates, which are not
prevalent in the far central north, or over-utilisation of the
species as a forage (reported on several herbarium
specimens), thus reducing population sizes.
The holotype of Pteronia seitziana was destroyed in
Berlin, and we designate the P collection, indicated as
“isotype” (unlike the collections in SAM) as the lectotype. The name P. feldtmanniana used by Dinter on his
collections was listed by Merxmüller (1955: 79) as
synonymous with P. eenii, but was never validly published.
8. Pteronia glabrata L. f. (Linnaeus filius 1782: 356);
Thunberg (1800: 143); de Candolle (1836: 362);
Harvey in Harvey & Sonder (1865: 102); Hutchinson
& Phillips (1917: 321); Dinter (1926: 132, 1931: 167);
Range (1935: 275); Merxmüller (1952: 125; 1967: 155);
Merxmüller & Roessler (1984: 89); Herman (2003:
277). Type: South Africa, Western Cape Prov., Cape of
Good Hope, Thunberg s.n. (holotype UPS-THUNB;
isotype S-G-5142!).
Pteronia sesuviifolia DC. (de Candolle 1836: 360). Type:
South Africa, Western Cape Prov., Kaus, R III, 1835,
Drège s.n. [2778] (G-DC no. G-00322348! lectotype,
selected here). — see Notes.
Pteronia carnosa Muschl. (Muschler 1911a: 95). Type:
Namibia, Lüderitzbucht, 4 Jan. 1910, Dinter 1026
(holotype B†; isotype SAM-71804-0!).
Pteronia succulenta auct. non Thunb.: Dinter (1926:
132); Range (1935: 276).
Pteronia anisata Dinter ex Merxm. (Merxmüller 1952:
124 – 125), nom. nud.
Pteronia glabrata L. f. var. succulenta (Thunb.) Merxm.
(Merxmüller 1952: 125), quoad specim. cit., non
quoad basionym.
Shrub, to 60 cm tall. Stems glabrous, brittle, initially with
pale grey bark, brown when older. Leaves opposite,
fleshy to succulent, glabrous, flattish, oblong to linear,
boat-shaped, adaxially grooved, to 10 – 25 × 3 – 5 mm,
apex rounded, base clasping stem but not connate
with opposite leaf. Capitula solitary, terminal, ovoid, to
20 × 15 mm, apex rounded in bud. Receptacle
honeycombed and slightly fimbriate. Phyllaries
multiseriate, gradate, broadly ovate to orbiculate, 3 –
15 mm long, glabrous, papery and brown at maturity,
opaque central part green with red margin; apex
rounded; margins narrow, membranous all round.
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
9488, Page 13 of 44
Florets 7 – 12; corollas c. 10 mm long, glabrous, bright
yellow; lobes linear-lanceolate, subacute; tube gradually widening. Achenes turbinate, densely appressed
villous, to 3.5 mm long. Pappus multiseriate, setae
connate at base, to 10 mm long, brown to golden.
Fig. 3.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Namibia, South Africa. Map 8.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Karas Region, Lüderitz
Distr.: Diamond Area No 1, Chamnaub Inselberg, NE
of Boegoeberg, 28 Aug. 2002, Bartsch, Loots &
Mannheimer SB930 (WIND!); Diamond Area 1,
Namitsis Inselberg, about 30 km S of Klinghardts, 1
Sept. 2002, Bartsch, Loots & Mannheimer SB956
(WIND!); Diamond Area 1, at foot of Tsabiams Mtn,
4 Sept. 2002, Bartsch, Loots & Mannheimer SB1021
(WIND!); Diamond Area 1, en route from Tsabiams to
Grillental, 5 Sept. 2002, Bartsch, Loots & Mannheimer
SB1031 (WIND!); Diamond Area 1, Rote Kuppe –
Chamais road, 6 Sept. 2002, Bartsch, Loots &
Mannheimer SB1036 (WIND!); Diamond Area No 1, S
of Lüderitz, about 48 km from Pomona on road to
Klinghardts Mts, 4 Aug. 2001, Burgoyne 8286 (PRE,
WIND!); Diamond Area 1, Klinghardts Mts, 21 Sept.
Fig. 3. Flowering Pteronia glabrata.
Map 8. Known distribution of Pteronia glabrata in Namibia.
1996, Burke 96115 (WIND!); Oranjemund. Gais area, E
of Hohenfels on the road to Jakkalsberge, 5 Sept.
1958, De Winter & Giess 6201 (PRE, WIND!); Mile 50
PHOTO: H. KOLBERG.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 14 of 44
on road Lüderitz to Oranjemund, 6 Sept. 1958, De
Winter & Giess 6224 (PRE, WIND!); Farm Spitskop LU
111, 35 km (22 miles) N of Lorelei Copper mine on
road to Witputs, 15 Sept. 1958, De Winter & Giess 6411
(PRE, WIND!); Lüderitzbucht, 4 Jan. 1910, Dinter 1026
(P. carnosa isotype SAM-71804-0!); Alicetal bei Pomona, 13 Aug. 1929, Dinter 6591 (NBG-202184-0, PRE160652-0); E of Oranjemund, 34 km from the check
point on the road to Sendelingsdrif, 25 Sept. 1997,
Gess & Gess 97/98/64 (WIND!); 3 km (2 miles) SE of
Lüderitz, 9 Aug. 1959, Giess & Van Vuuren 731 (PRE,
WIND!); S of Lüderitzbucht, on the way to the
lighthouse, 12 Sept. 1967, Giess 10196 (WIND!); About
40 km N of Rosh Pinah, Farm Witpütz Süd, 29 Sept.
1983, Goldblatt 7019 (PRE, WIND!); Namuskluft, 28
Oct. 1970, Jankowitz 12/190 (WIND!); Ai-Ais conservation area, McMillan's Pass, 2 km SE of summit of pass
along track, 12 Oct. 2005, Kolberg & Tholkes HK1698
(K!, WIND!); Sperrgebiet. Lüderitz – Oranjemund
road at N turn-off to Bogenfels, 14 Oct. 2006, Kolberg
& Tholkes HK2103 (K!, WIND!); Tafelberg, SE of
Klinghardts, Sperrgebiet, Aug. 1971, Logan & Jensen
899 (WIND!); Tafelberg, N of Affenrücken (coast),
Sperrgebiet 1, Aug. 1971, Logan & Jensen 959
(WIND!); Just outside Lüderitz on road to Aus, 15
Aug. 2001, Loots SL114 (WIND!); Lüderitz –
Oranjemund road, 27 Aug. 2002, Mannheimer
CM2021 (WIND!); Namitsas, S of Klinghardt Basin, 1
Sept. 2002, Mannheimer 2110 (WIND!); Namitsas, S of
Klinghardt Basin, 1 Sept. 2002, Mannheimer CM2122
(WIND!); Limestone-dolomite ridge, NE Klinghardts,
3 Sept. 2002, Mannheimer CM2175 (WIND!); Road to
Grillental from Kaukausib, 5 Sept. 2002, Mannheimer
CM2201 (WIND!); Blue ridges at Pomona
pumphouse, 27 Sept. 2004, Mannheimer, Maggs-Kölling
& Loots CM2646 (WIND!); Road between Grillental
and Drachenberg, 9 Sept. 2005, Mannheimer CM2737
(WIND!); Nautilus, N of Lüderitz, 23 Aug. 1963,
Merxmüller & Giess 3074 (M, WIND!); Farm Spitzkop,
plain before Numais-bank, 1 Sept. 1963, Merxmüller &
Giess 3412 (M, PRE, WIND!); Lüderitzbucht, 8 Sept.
1972, Merxmüller & Giess 28277 (M, PRE, WIND!);
Buchuberge, 10 Sept. 1972, Merxmüller & Giess 28302
(M, PRE, WIND!); 23 km S of Grillental, 12 Sept. 1972,
Merxmüller & Giess 28380 (M, PRE, WIND!);
Klinghardt Mts, S part, in the region of Sargdeckel,
17 Sept. 1977, Merxmüller & Giess 32109 (M, PRE,
WIND!); Klinghardt Mts, near foot of the mountain,
27 July 1977, Müller 699 (WIND!); Schakals Mts, 31 July
1977, Müller 756 (PRE, WIND!); Sperrgebiet, on main
road between Lüderitz and Oranjemund, 14 Aug.
2001, Smook 11383 (PRE, WIND!); (Buchuberg) Found
on NW slope, 28 Sept. 1992, Strohbach 218 (WIND!);
Namuskluft, 22 Aug. 1989, Strohbach 458 (WIND!);
McMillians Pass, 23 Aug. 1989, Strohbach 486 (WIND!);
Rosh Pinah, Namuskluft 88, 31 Aug. 1989, Van Wyk
8822 (PRE, WIND!); Farm Zebrafontein 87, Mountains
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
near farmhouse on Spitskop 111, Feb. 1989, Van Wyk
8986 (PRE, WIND!); Diamond area no. 1, Obib
Springs, where the stream exits from the mountain, 3
Sept. 1989, Van Wyk 9041 (PRE, WIND!); 30 km S of
Auffenrücken, June 1993, Williamson 4617 (WIND!);
30 km S of Affenrücken, June 1993, Williamson 4618
(WIND!); Daberas gorge, 55 km NE of Oranjemund,
16 July 1993, Williamson 5035 (WIND!); 10 km S of
Chameis gate, 110 km N of Oranjemund, 21 July 1993,
Williamson 5075 (WIND!). SOUTH AFRICA. Western
Cape Prov.: Cape of Good Hope, Thunberg s.n. (P.
glabrata holotype UPS-THUNB; isotype S-G-5142)!);
Kaus, R III, 1835, Drège s.n. [2778] (P. sesuviifolia
lectotype G-DC no. G-00322348!); Olifant R. W (of
“West”?), R I, 1835, Drège s.n. [?778 or 2778] (P.
sesuviifolia syntypes G-DC no G-00322349!, P-027091!,
P-27092!, P-027093 (ex hb. Hennecart)!); possible
syntypes HAL-0110985!, HBG-505117!, HBG-503991!,
NY-00232709!).
HABITAT. In gravel or sand of plains and hill slopes in
steppe dominated by succulents; mostly near the coast;
50 – 800 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. The Namibian distribution of
this species falls almost entirely into the protected
diamond mining area, which has now been declared a
national park, limiting human access and activity. The
effect of mining on Pteronia glabrata is minimal since
mining is restricted to small areas and governed by a
sound environmental management policy. The species is
widely distributed (large estimated EOO and AOO) and
no threats could be identified, thus resulting in a
Namibian evaluation of LC (IUCN 2001, 2013). The
South African threat status is listed as LC (SANBI 2011).
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: February to October. Fruiting:
June to November.
NOTES. Among earlier collectors in Namibia there has
been some confusion around this species and its
difference (or not) to Pteronia succulenta. Material of
P. succulenta, which occurs only in South Africa, must
be inspected to verify if these are two separate species
or not, but this falls outside the scope of this study.
The syntypes of Pteronia sesuviifolia in G-DC are on
one sheet: “Kaus, Drège, and Olifantrivier, Drège”, with
both showing the number 2778. (On the Olifantrivier
collection the label number is unclear and appears to
have the 2 and the first of the two number 7s
superimposed, raising the impression of “778” only.)
We have selected the Kaus material as lectotype
because, though lacking (parts of) flowers, the overall
quality of the material is better. It should be noted
that, here and elsewhere, after designating a lectotype
the remainder of all original material (if any) is not to
be named “paralectotype” or “lectoparatype” (whatever one prefers), but remain “syntype(s)” in accordance
with Turland’s (2013: 62) interpretation — an opinion
we have followed in all cases where we have chosen a
lectotype among syntypes.
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
There are syntypes of the Olifantrivier collection in
P (P-027091!, P-27092!, P-027093 (ex hb.
Hennecart)!)) and G-DC (G-00322349!). Potential
syntypes have annotations, sometimes indicating effectively the same location but lack the number 2778
(unlike the P specimens) or lack the precise locality.
We identified HAL-0110985, HBG-505117, HBG503991 and NY-00232709 in this respect.
A Drège specimen at Vienna, W-0008793, has a
locality "near Kaus" and what we assumed to be a
collecting date, "1837-12" (Dec. 1837), but which is
probably a herbarium dispatch or a receipt date.
Similarly, W-0008794 shows “1837-12” and is from near
the Ebenezar, Olifantrivier locality. We therefore exclude these specimens as syntypes. Also W-Rchb. 18890292322 is not exactly from any of the two locations in
the protologue and should also, we believe, be excluded
as original material — contrary to the annotations in W.
9488, Page 15 of 44
splitting on older stems. Leaves opposite, clustered
along stems, densely silver-grey felty, linear to linearlanceolate, 4 – 10 × 2 – 2.5 mm, apex obtuse or
subacute, base sessile; aromatic. Capitula numerous,
densely covering plant, all along branches, narrowelongate ellipsoid to turbinate, 12 – 15 × 8 mm; apex
acute in bud. Receptacle fimbriate. Phyllaries
multiseriate, outer broadly lanceolate, inner oblonglanceolate, yellow to straw-coloured; grey felty on
outside; midrib pubescent, thickened towards apex
but never tapering into a mucro; apex acute; margins
narrow glabrescent, indistinctly ciliate. Florets c. 4;
corollas to 10 mm long, yellow; lobes triangular, obtuse;
tube widening upwards, ribbed at base. Achenes
obovate, contracted into a distinct neck, villous in
lower half, to 3 mm long. Pappus multiseriate, c. 10
mm long, straw-coloured.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Botswana, Namibia, South Africa.
Map 9.
9. Pteronia glauca Thunb. (Thunberg 1800: 144); de
Candolle (1836: 365); Harvey in Harvey & Sonder
(1865: 107); Hutchinson & Phillips (1917: 289); Range
(1935: 275); Merxmüller (1955: 79; 1967: 156);
Merxmüller & Roessler (1984: 90); Herman (2003:
277). Type: South Africa, Western Cape Prov., Cape of
Good Hope, Thunberg s.n. (holotype UPS-THUNB;
isotype LD-1254625!).
Pteronia latisquama DC. (de Candolle 1836: 363). Type:
South Africa, Northern Cape Prov., Zwischen
(noted on label as “Zw:”) Camisberge und OnderBokkeveld, R V, 1835, Drège s.n. [607] (holotype GDC no. G-00322350!). — see Notes.
Pteronia glabrata auct. non L. f.: de Candolle (1836:
362); Hutchinson & Phillips (1917: 289, noting
“DC, not of L. f.”).
Pteronia candollei Harv. (Harvey in Harvey & Sonder
1865: 105, “Candollei”). Type: South Africa, Northern Cape Prov., Fraserburg Div., between Karree R.
and Quaggas Fontein, Burchell 1410 (holotype K00273422!).
Pteronia thymifolia Muschl. & Dinter (Muschler 1911a:
100). Type: Namibia, Bezirk des Damaralandes,
Farm Hoffnung, 1900 m, 20 Aug. 1909, Dinter 967
(holotype B†; isotypes K-00273419!, K-000273424!,
SAM-71826-0).
Pteronia arcuata Dinter (1932: 182). Type: Namibia,
Aus, in der Mesembr.-Steppe am Wege nach
Gubub [Kubub], 26 Oct. 1922, Dinter 4152 (holotype B†; isotypes HBG-505144!, PRE-156640-0, SAM71805-0, Z-000052352!, Z-000052353!, Z000003814!), synon. nov.
Pteronia glauca Thunb. subsp. arcuata (Dinter) Merxm.
(Merxmüller 1955: 79; 1967: 156).
Shrub, to 80 cm tall and 120 cm in diam. Stems
sometimes arching to ground, grey pubescent, bark
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Erongo Region,
Omaruru Distr.: Brandberg, upper reaches of
Königstein, 5 May 1993, Craven 4010 (WIND!); Valleys
of upper Brandberg Mt, June 1955, Wiss 1427 (PRE,
WIND!); Hardap Region, Maltahöhe Distr.: (Naukluft
Park) 17 May 1979, Cronje 2 (WIND!); No 9. NaukluftPlateau, 9 April 1971, Meyer 491 966 (WIND!); Karas
Region, Bethanie Distr.: Farm Gamochas BET 31, 6
Sept. 1972, Merxmüller & Giess 28257 (M, PRE,
WIND!); Keetmanshoop Distr.: Farm Witmond, on
rim of W plateau, 31 March 1998, Strohbach & Dauth
3826 (WIND!); Farm Rishon, on top of Graberberg at
Telecom tower, 1 April 1998, Strohbach & Dauth 3835
(WIND!); Lüderitz Distr.: Aus, Mesembr.-Steppe along
road to Gubub [Kubub], 26 Oct. 1922, Dinter 4152 (P.
Map 9. Known distribution of Pteronia glauca in Namibia.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 16 of 44
arcuata isotypes HBG-505144!, PRE-156640-0, SAM71805-0, Z-000052352!, Z-000052353!, Z-000003814!);
Farm Klein Aus, W of Aus, 11 Aug. 1959, Giess & Van
Vuuren 768 (PRE, WIND!); Aus, Kubub, 4 Oct. 1959,
Giess 2387 (PRE, WIND!); Farm Zebrafontein, track
from road D463; at locked gate just before homestead,
20 Oct. 2007, Kolberg & Tholkes HK2410 (K!, WIND!);
Sperrgebiet, 19 km S of Obib Fountain, track turns E
and leads over hill, 24 Oct. 2008, Kolberg & Tholkes
HK2694 (K!, WIND!); Farm Plateau LU 38, 8 Sept.
1963, Kräusel & Wiss 2015 (WIND!); (Aus) quartz
foothills, 17 Sept. 2005, Mannheimer CM2822 (WIND!);
Aus, in the river on the way to Helmeringhausen, 7 Aug.
1963, Merxmüller & Giess 2918 (M, PRE, WIND!);
Klinghardt Mts, near top of the mountain, 28 July
1977, Müller 703 (PRE, WIND!); Farm Plateau, Aus, 13
April 1953, Walter & Walter 2555 (WIND!); Maltahöhe
Distr.: Farm Chamchawib, Helmeringhausen, 15 Aug.
1963, Merxmüller & Giess 2812 (M, PRE, WIND!);
Khomas Region, Windhoek Distr.: Windhoek, 1955,
Basson 137 (WIND!); Khomas Hochland, 14 May 2000,
Burke 00089 (WIND!); Farm Hoffnung, 20 Aug. 1909,
Dinter 967 (P. thymifolia isotypes K-00273419!, K000273424!, SAM-71826-0); Lichtenstein, 15 Oct. 1934,
Dinter 7892 (Z!); Windhoek, Augeigas, Daan Viljoen
road, turn-off to Matchless Mine, ± 500 m from turn-off,
6 Aug. 2000, Friedrich FRI2 43 (WIND!); Farm Keres
WIN 39, on the Kereshöhe, 6 Nov. 1965, Giess 9038
(PRE, WIND!); Moltkeblick, Auasberge, 29 Aug. 1971,
Giess & Von Alvensleben 11493 (PRE, WIND!); Farm
Hohenau, Aug. 1963, Kräusel & Wiss 1994 (WIND!);
Farm Harris, 19 July 1965, Leach, Bayliss & Giess 12938
(PRE, WIND!); Farm Regenstein, below SW mountain
foot towards plain, 22 Aug. 1972, Merxmüller & Giess
28008 (M, PRE, WIND!); Farm Regenstein, near
Windhoek, 12 April 1953, Schwerdtfeger 2/294 (WIND!);
Farm Bellerode, 13 km (8 miles) from Windhoek, 17
March 1965, Toelken & Hardy 712 (PRE, WIND!); Farm
Immental, Von Koenen s.n. (WIND-34158!); Farm
Voigtland, Okamatuja, 17 Nov. 1952, Walter & Walter
118 (WIND!). SOUTH AFRICA. Western Cape Prov.:
Boschjemanskarroo [III A b 1], Drège s.n. (HAL0111565!, HBG-505116!, HBG-503989!, P-027102!, P027103!, P-00179775!, PRE, W-0008795); Aasvogelberg
[II e 11], Drège s.n. (HAL-0111564!, K-000273420!, P00179776!, P-027104!, P-027101!, P-027100!, W0008796!); Fraserburg Div., between Karree R. and
Quaggas Fontein, Burchell 1410 (P. candollei holotype K00273422!); Cape of Good Hope, Thunberg s.n. (P.
glauca holotype UPS-THUNB; isotype LD-1254625!);
Northern Cape Prov.: between Camisberge and OnderBokkeveld, R V, 1835, Drège s.n. [607] (P. latisquama
holotype G-DC no. G-00322350!).
HABITAT. Rocky hills and mountains in high-altitude
shrubland, dwarf shrub savanna, desert-dwarf shrub
transition and steppe dominated by succulent species;
450 – 1900 m.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
CONSERVATION STATUS. This species is evaluated LC in
Namibia with a very large estimated EOO and AOO
that puts it outside the thresholds for threatened
species (IUCN 2013). In addition, no threats causing
population decline could be identified. The threat
status for South Africa is also listed as Least Concern
(LC) (SANBI 2011).
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: May to November. Fruiting:
September to December.
VERNACULAR NAMES. Boegoekaroo, geelboegoekaroo,
perdekaroo (Afrikaans, South Africa).
NOTES. This species is restricted to higher altitudes or
mountains in Namibia. Plants with arching branches
found near Aus were described as Pteronia arcuata
Dinter, later considered a subspecies of P. glauca
(Merxmüller 1955: 79). The arching branches, however, are not consistently displayed. Plants with arching
and non-arching branches have been found by the
first author in the same population. The stem habit
seems to be determined by the plant’s environment
and arching branches occur mostly on plants in hard,
rocky soil, such as the specimens near Aus. For this
reason subsp. arcuata is not upheld here.
An enumeration of localities and species collected
by J. F. Drège in southern Africa (mainly in presentday South Africa) was published in 1843 (Drège 1843)
with an introduction (on pp. 3 – 43) by E. Meyer. It is
structured along an elaborate site coding system, using
numerals and letters such as I, II, III, A, B, a, b, 1, 2,
etc., a combination of which is often found on what
have been or are being designated (iso) types of, in
our case, Pteronia species. For example “III.E.a” in
association with P. sesuviifolia (q.v.) is listed by Drège in
1843 on p. 108. Although this works well with most
species as a precise source of additional locality data it
fails with P. latisquama where none of the potential
isotypes is directly linked to (part of) the “Camisberge,
Onder-Bokkeveld” of the holotype. One also needs to
keep in mind that this enumeration was published six
years after de Candolle’s 1836 treatment of the genus
in the fifth volume of his Prodromus — and thus that
Candolle’s locality names could easily have been
included in the Drège listing. That localities in the
protologue by de Candolle do not match any in
Drège/Meyer was already annotated in association
with specimens in W (0008795 and -8796; see below)
by L. Pignotti. We found two sets of specimens with
the name P. latisquama, but have been unable to link
any of them to the holotype locality. One set of
specimens carries: (1) Boschjemanskarroo (the locality
“III A b 1” in Drège 1843: 69), found in HAL-0111565!,
HBG-505116!, HBG-503989!, P-027102!, P-027103!, P00179775!, PRE, and W-0008795!, sometimes with the
(presumed) de Candolle number [607] added. The
name is also on K-000273421!, but we exclude this as
“1837” is cited, which is possibly a herbarium despatch
or receipt date. Of all these specimens P-027103 seems
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
9488, Page 17 of 44
the most authentic as we think it shows an original
Drege label with his handwriting and with “III A b
1” cited. The other carries: (2) Aasvogelberg (the
locality II.e.11 in Drège 1843: 65), and is present
in HAL-0111564!, K-000273420!, P-00179776!, P027104!, P-027101!, P-027100!, W-0008796!.
10. Pteronia inflexa L. f. (Linnaeus filius 1782: 356);
Thunberg (1800: 144); de Candolle (1836: 365);
Harvey in Harvey & Sonder (1865: 99); Hutchinson
& Phillips (1917: 300); Merxmüller (1967: 156);
Merxmüller & Roessler (1984: 90); Herman (2003:
278). Type: South Africa, Western Cape Prov., Cape of
Good Hope, Thunberg s.n. (holotype UPS-THUNB;
isotype LD-1254505!).
Pteronia lupulina DC. (de Candolle 1836: 357).
Type: South Africa, Northern Cape Prov.,
Fraserburg, between Zack R. and Kopjes
Fontein, 4 Sept. 1811, Burchell 1495 (holotype
G-DC; isotypes K-00273447!, P-027188!, PRE157943-0, W-0008801!).
Pteronia lupulina DC. var. rotundifolia DC. (de Candolle
1836: 358). Type: South Africa, Western Cape Prov.,
Nieuweveld, R IV, 1835, Drège s.n. [767] (holotype GDC no. G-00322347!; isotypes may exist — see Notes).
Shrub, to 30 cm tall. Stems sparingly pubescent, bark
pale grey to grey, splitting on old growth. Leaves
opposite, coriaceous, surface densely short bristly and
sessile glandular, flat, elliptic to narrowly ovate, 5 – 15
× 4 mm; apex rounded; base sessile; margins pectinate.
Capitula solitary on short branchlets, ovoid-campanulate, 15 – 20 × 6 – 10 mm; apex rounded to truncate in
bud. Receptacle honeycombed. Phyllaries multiseriate,
ovate to orbicular, to 5 × 3 mm, green to brown,
glabrous except for a few glands on outside; apex
rounded; margins distinct, translucent, membranous.
Florets c. 10; corollas to 10 mm long, glabrous, yellow;
lobes lanceolate, subacute; tube gradually widening.
Achenes obconical, sparsely villous, to 4 mm long.
Pappus c. 10 mm long, straw-coloured.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Namibia, South Africa. Map 10.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Hardap Region,
Maltahöhe Distr.: Farm Naudaus/Duwisib MAL 76/
84, 10 May 1956, Volk 12771 (WIND!); Farm Naudaus/
Duwisib 76/84, 3 May 1956, Volk 12772 (WIND!); Karas
Region, Bethanie Distr.: Farm Goais BET 13, 23 June
1974, Giess 13353 (PRE, WIND!); Keetmanshoop
Distr.: Farm Witmond 162A, NW of farmhouse on
sloping plain, 14 Feb. 1997, Strohbach, Kubirske &
Sheuyange 2872 (WIND!); Lüderitz Distr.: Farm Plateau, 20 Aug. 1963, Merxmüller & Giess 3012 (M, PRE,
WIND!). SOUTH AFRICA. Western Cape Prov.: Cape of
Good Hope, Thunberg s.n. (P. inflexa holotype UPSTHUNB; isotype LD-1254505!); Fraserburg, between
Map 10. Known distribution of Pteronia inflexa in Namibia.
Zack R. and Kopjes Fontein, 4 Sept. 1811, Burchell 1495
(P. lupulina holotype G-DC; isotypes K-00273447!, P027188!, PRE-157943-0, W-0008801!); Nieuweveld, R
IV, 1835, Drège s.n. [767] (P. lupulina var. rotundifolia
holotype G-DC no. G-00322347!); between Waschbank
and Rietpoort, Nieuweveld, 3500 (ft.), (loc.) I d, 26
Nov. 1826, Drège s.n. (P-027186!).
HABITAT. Gravelly plains and slopes of dwarf shrub
savanna and desert. None of the Namibian specimens
examined present any altitudinal data.
CONSERVATION STATUS. The uncertain identity of
Namibian specimens (see Notes) together with insufficient information on these led us to conclude that
the status Data Deficient (DD) must be assigned for
Namibia (IUCN 2001, 2013). Least Concern (LC) is
recorded as the South African threat status (SANBI
2011).
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: February to August.
NOTES. According to Hutchinson & Phillips (1917)
this species belongs to what they called sect. Ciliatae
with ciliate leaf margins. The leaves of Namibian
collections are, however, papillate-glandular and do
not have ciliate margins, which would put the
species into their sect. Papillatae. In Hutchinson &
Phillips’ (1917) description of Pteronia inflexa there
is also no mention of ciliate or pectinate leaf
margins. P. inflexa has rarely been recorded in
Namibia and the distribution in south-western and
south-eastern Namibia is disjunct from its distribution in the Karoo of South Africa. More Namibian
material must be collected and compared with
South African specimens to verify if P. inflexa does
indeed occur in Namibia or if these specimens
belong to another species.
Possible isotypes of Pteronia lupulina var. rotundifolia
may exist: relevant specimens in P (e.g. P-027186! and
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 18 of 44
027187!) and W (e.g. W-Rchb.-1889-0292329! and W0020460) all show the handwritten annotation of the
full name, but do not show the year or associated
number 767.
11. Pteronia leucoclada Turcz. (Turczaninow 1851: 65);
Harvey in Harvey & Sonder (1865: 105); Hutchinson &
Phillips (1917: 314); Merxmüller (1967: 156);
Merxmüller & Roessler (1984: 90); Herman (2003: 278).
Type: South Africa, Western Cape Prov., Cape of Good
Hope, Zeyher 811 (holotype KW-001000912!; isotypes K000273482!, K-000273483!, K-000273484!, P-027205!, P027206!, PRE-0159187-0!, PRE-0587284-0!, SAM-00377380!, W-Rchb.-1889-0278261!, Z-000052407!).
Shrub, to 50 cm tall. Stems smooth, glabrous, white when
young. Leaves alternate, clustered along stem, fleshy,
glabrous, oblong to narrowly obovate-clavate, to 7 × 1.5
mm; apex rounded; narrowed into base. Capitula
solitary, terminal, obconic to almost spherical, to 15 ×
10 mm, apex rounded in bud. Receptacle honeycombed,
fimbriate. Phyllaries multiseriate, lanceolate to linear,
keeled, 2 – 3 mm long, inner phyllaries to 2.5 mm broad,
glabrous; apex acuminate; margins membranous. Florets
c. 20; corollas to 5.5 mm long, yellow; lobes unequal,
triangular-lanceolate, subacute. Achenes compressed turbinate, densely villous, to 2 mm long. Pappus
multiseriate, sparsely barbellate, to 6 mm long, golden.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Namibia, South Africa. Map 11.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Karas Region,
Karasburg Distr.: Farm Vrede, 19 July 2005, Bruyns
10107 (BOL, WIND!); Klein Karas, 6 Aug. 1923, Dinter
4849 (Z!); Farm Klein-Aub WAR 52, 17 May 1963,
Map 11. Known distribution of Pteronia leucoclada in
Namibia.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
Giess, Volk & Bleissner 7022 (PRE, WIND!); Farm
Udabis WAR 77, 19 May 1963, Giess, Volk & Bleissner
7108 (WIND!); Near border between Huniam Ost and
Uheib 84, 19 April 1997, Strohbach 3429 (WIND!);
Keetmanshoop Distr.: Klein Karas Mts, 6 March 1999,
Burke 99149 (WIND!). SOUTH AFRICA. Western Cape
Prov.: Cape of Good Hope, Zeyher 811 (holotype KW001000912!; isotypes K-000273482!, K-000273483!, K000273484!, P-027205!, P-027206!, PRE-0159187-0!,
PRE-0587284-0!, SAM-0037738-0!, W-Rchb.-18890278261!, Z-000052407!)
HABITAT. Dwarf shrubland; c. 950 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. This species has a relatively
restricted range in SE Namibia and present information suggests that it is rare here. The estimated EOO
would qualify it for VU status but no two of the
additional three criteria under criterion B can be
satisfied (IUCN 2013). For criterion D2 the number of
localities is restricted but no additionally required
plausible future threat could be identified to qualify
Pteronia leucoclada as VU. The Namibian conservation
status is thus assessed here as LC (IUCN 2001).
The South African threat status is also LC (SANBI
2011).
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: March to July. Fruiting: April.
V E R N A C U L A R N A M E S . Bleekbossie, witbossie,
witbasbossie (Afrikaans, South Africa).
NOTES. Thus far only a few collections have been made
from the extreme south-east of Namibia. The greater
part of the species’ range falls into adjacent areas in
South Africa.
Although Turczaninow cites “Zeyher coll. n. 811.” it is
often impossible to separate Zeyher from “Ecklon &
Zeyher” collections — indeed the isotype in Z carries a
label to that extent and does not indicate who of the
two actually collected no. 811. (In contrast, K, KW,
SAM, P-027206, PRE and W-Rchb. all have “Zeyher 811”
as the sole collector.) Ecklon & Zeyher’s collections
from “S. Africa” (Lanjouw & Stafleu 1957: 176) are in
many herbaria. They are not, however, reported from
KW where Turczaninow’s types are, and thus the type
of leucoclada from KW presents a rare exception. We
follow Stafleu & Cowan (1986: 538) on the location of
the type, which in this case also carries “verified by
Turczaninow”.
As with other Pteronia species (see above), the
various isotypes provide more locality details than the
holotype: the SAM and W-Rchb. collections have
“Bitterfontein, Bosmansland” on the label. Isotype P027205 has the Zeyher 811 “communicated” by Drège,
and with the locality described as: “Clanwilliam. A
Tulbaghskloof ad Pikenierskloof. 500′ – 1000′.
Martii.”. However, this annotation is certainly not in
Zeyher’s handwriting. Furthermore, P-027206 is the
only isotype with a year of collecting: 1847. Though
the total of these isotypes provides much more detail,
they are not necessarily Zeyher’s notes.
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
12. Pteronia lucilioides DC. (de Candolle 1836: 358);
Harvey in Harvey & Sonder (1865: 100); Hutchinson &
Phillips (1917: 293); Dinter (1926: 132); Range (1935:
275); Merxmüller (1952: 126; 1967: 156); Merxmüller
& Roessler (1984: 90); Herman (2003: 278). Type:
South Africa, Northern Cape Prov., Klein Namaqualand, R. II, Drège s.n. [2779] (holotype G-DC; isotype P027210!).
Pteronia lucilioides DC. var. β sparsifolia Harv. (Harvey in
Harvey & Sonder 1865: 100). Type: South Africa,
Namaqualand, Wyley s.n. (not traced).
Pteronia gymnocline auct. non DC.: (Meyer in) Drège
(1843: 94, 214); Range (1935: 275); Hutchinson &
Phillips (1917: 294). — see Notes.
Pteronia bromoides S. Moore (1904: 1011). Type:
Namibia, Gross Namaland, Jakalskopje, Dinter
1197 (holotype BM-000903815!).
Pteronia beckeoides auct. non DC.: Dinter (1926: 132);
Range (1935: 275, “beckioides”); Merxmüller (1955:
80).
Pteronia roesemanniana Dinter ex Merxm. (Merxmüller
1952: 128; 1955: 80), nom. nud. — see Notes.
Shrub to 2.5 m tall, virgate, sparsely branched; near
coast only to 30 cm high and much-branched. Stems
scabrid-puberulous, glabrescent, grey. Leaves opposite,
clustered on stems, matte grey-green, surface with
acute conical, multicellular papillae interspersed with
sessile, spherical glands, linear to obovate or oblongspathulate, boat-shaped, 5 – 8 × 1.5 mm; apex obtuse;
base sessile, not connate with opposite leaf. Capitula
solitary, terminal, cylindrical, 15 – 20 × 5 – 10 mm;
apex sharply acute in bud. Receptacle deeply
honeycombed. Phyllaries multiseriate, oblong-oblanceolate to linear-oblong, 6 –18 × 3 – 5 mm, pale
yellow, glabrous except for finely puberulous outer
midrib; apex rounded to subacute to cuspidate;
margins not distinctly membranous. Florets c. 12;
corollas to 10 mm long, yellow; lobes lanceolate,
subacute; tube gradually widening. Achenes obovoidturbinate, densely glandular and sparsely setose, to 6
mm long. Pappus multiseriate, barbellate, to 10 mm
long, straw-coloured. Figs 4 – 5.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Namibia, South Africa. Map 12.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Erongo Region,
Karibib Distr.: Okongava, Kalkberge, 2 Feb. 1934,
Dinter 6933 (K-000273436!, PRE, WIND!); Farm
Okongawa, Marmorberg, 9 May 1958, Seydel 1553
(WIND!); Hardap Region, Maltahöhe Distr.: Losberg,
path to the repeater, very close to the top and on
highest plateau, 1 July 2004, Clapham & Drayer 145
(WIND!); Mountain Zebra Park, Naukluft MAL 9, 2
June 1968, Giess 10445 (PRE, WIND!); Found above
the Hudup R., some 1.6 km N of Maltahöhe, 5 Sept.
1972, Merxmüller & Giess 28222 (M, PRE, WIND!);
Farm Naudaus/Duwisib, Helmeringhausen, 20 May
9488, Page 19 of 44
1956, Volk 12496 (WIND!); Near Farm Maguams,
slopes of Schwarzrand, 22 March 1953, Walter & Walter
2115 (WIND!); Karas Region, Bethanie Distr.: 38 km
(23.5 miles) N of Helmeringhausen, 19 Oct. 1949,
Acocks 15631 (PRE, WIND!); Farm Mara, kloof on E
side of Konkiep near house, 11 July 1988, Craven 3310
(WIND!); Farm Mara, O'Connell's prospecting kloof,
in Hunsberg Mts, above middle windpump, 24 Sept.
1989, Craven 3521 (WIND!); Farm Mara E of Hunsberg
Mts, In kloof of mountain, W of farm house, 23 June
1991, Craven 3862 (WIND!); Farm Mooifontein BET
50, 19 May 1965, Giess 8817 (PRE, WIND!); Farm
Heigums BET 105, 16 June 1976, Giess & Müller 14433
(WIND!); Farm Chamchawib, Helmeringhausen, 15
Aug. 1963, Merxmüller & Giess 2813 (M, PRE, WIND!);
Farm Kosos, 15 Aug. 1963, Merxmüller & Giess 2819 (M,
PRE, WIND!); Farm Saraus BET 16, 5 Sept. 1972,
Merxmüller & Giess 28226 (M, PRE, WIND!); Farm
Aruab 23, near Aris Post, 5 April 1998, Miller MIL1/ 55
(WIND!); Karasburg Distr.: Farm Kromrivier WAR 359,
May 1963, Giess, Volk & Bleissner 6997 (WIND!); Farm
Sperlingspüts WAR 259, 6 Aug. 1976, Giess 14516
(WIND!); Spes Bona, 31 Aug. 1970, Jankowitz 81/1493
(WIND!); Karas Mt on route to the Telecom tower on
farm Rishon, 14 Feb. 1997, Strohbach 2854 (WIND!);
Goodhouse Poort, 29 Aug. 1989, Van Wyk 8711 (PRE,
WIND!); Keetmanshoop Distr.: 56 km (35 miles) SW of
Narubis, 30 April 1955, Acocks 18045 (PRE, WIND!);
Farm Kochena KEE 74, in the mts N of the farmhouse,
12 May 1972, Giess & Müller 11895 (PRE, WIND!);
Farm Pieterskloof (Kraaikluft) KEE 370, Mt. N of
Schroffenstein, 14 May 1972, Giess & Müller 11926
(PRE, WIND!); Lüderitz Distr.: Diamond Area 1,
Drachenberg, 9 Sept. 2005, Bartsch, Mannheimer &
Kwembeya SB2048 (WIND!); Rosh Pinah.
Nooitgedacht, 10 Aug. 2000, Bruyns 8330 (BOL,
WIND!); Dik Willem, 29 April 2000, Burke 00076
(WIND!); SE of Aurus Mts, Sperrgebiet, 24 Sept.
1999, Burke 99212 (WIND!); SE of Aurus Mts,
Sperrgebiet, 24 Sept. 1999, Burke 99215 (WIND!);
Skorpion turn-off D716 c. 5 km N of Rosh Pinah,
Bührmann BUH1 76 (WIND!); Diamond area no. 1,
Grillental, marble hills, 6 Sept. 1958, De Winter & Giess
6228 (PRE, WIND!); Farm Namuskluft LU 88, c. 29 km
(18 miles) S on road to Lorelei, 13 Sept. 1958, De
Winter & Giess 6337 (NBG, PRE, SAM, WIND!); Great
Namaland, Jakalskopje, Dinter 1197 (P. bromoides holotype BM-000903815!); Kahanstal, 9 Dec. 1934, Dinter
8192 (K!); Hunsberge; in the Nuob R., 26 Sept. 1976,
Giess & Wendt 14714 (WIND!); Farm Witputz Nord
LUS 22, June 1976, Giess & Wendt 14783 (WIND!);
About 40 km N of Rosh Pinah, Farm Sud Witputs.
Granitic outcroppings NE of farm houses, 29 Sept.
1983, Goldblatt 7015 (PRE, WIND!); N of Witputz, 2
Oct. 1978, Hardy & Venter 4863 (PRE, WIND!);
Sperrgebiet, N Klinghardt Mts, 6 Aug. 2001, Klaassen
& Bartsch EK507 (WIND!); C13 on way to Rosh Pinah
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 20 of 44
Fig. 4. The typically acute budding capitula of Pteronia lucilioides.
from Aus, 8 Aug. 2001, Klaassen & Bartsch EK535
(WIND!); Sperrgebiet, 50 km from Rotkop Station,
powerline track, 23 Oct. 1987, Kolberg & Maggs HK210
(WIND!); Farm Klein Aus Vista, Geister Trail from
cabin in Geisterschlucht, rocky hill slopes to SW, 4
Oct. 2006, Kolberg & Tholkes HK2049 (K!, WIND!);
Namuskluft LU 88. Witputz, 13 Sept. 1963, Kräusel &
Wiss 2074 (WIND!); White quartz outcrop,
Sperrgebiet, 3 Sept. 1992, Kubirske, Strohbach & Swart
18 (WIND!); NW corner of the farm Namuskluft, 3
Feb. 1981, Lavranos, Barad & Pehlemann 19226
(WIND!); Namuskluft, July 1971, Logan 414/1493
(WIND!); Namuskluft, July 1971, Logan 414 (WIND!);
Between Klinghardts and Aurus towards Heioab, 12
Aug. 2001, Loots SL108 (WIND!); S of Tsaus
(Sperrgebiet), 26 Sept. 1996, Mannheimer &
Mannheimer 324 (WIND!); S of Tsaus (Sperrgebiet),
26 Sept. 1996, Mannheimer & Mannheimer 325
(WIND!); Rocky area next to borehole, near Aurus
Mts, 26 Sept. 1996, Mannheimer & Mannheimer 329
(WIND!); On kopje near access to Aurus basin, 28
Sept. 1996, Mannheimer & Mannheimer 383 (WIND!);
Aurus fountain on W-face, 9 Aug. 2001, Mannheimer
CM1545 (WIND!); N of Dik Willem, 31 July 2002,
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
PHOTO: H. KOLBERG.
Mannheimer 1933 (WIND!); Boegoeberg, N end of
ridge, 29 Aug. 2002, Mannheimer 2061 (WIND!);
Namitsas, S of Klinghardt Basin, 1 Sept. 2002,
Mannheimer CM2123 (WIND!); (Sperrgebiet), 3 Sept.
2002, Mannheimer CM2173 (WIND!); Road from
Grillental to Kaukausib, 5 Sept. 2002, Mannheimer
CM2206 (WIND!); Namuskluft farm, just SW of
MacMillans pass, 9 Sept. 2002, Mannheimer CM2221
(WIND!); Valley adjacent to Kahanstal, 12 km SE of
Rosh Pinah on road to Loreley, 21 Sept. 1972,
Merxmüller & Giess 28643 (M, PRE, WIND!); 9.5 km S
of Grillental, 15 Sept. 1977, Merxmüller & Giess 32021
(M, PRE, WIND!); Farm Spitzkop LUS 111, 25 Sept.
1977, Merxmüller & Giess 32310 (M, WIND!); Numaeis
South, Witputz, 1957, Rusch 4720 (WIND!);
Sperrgebiet, between Aurus and Klinghardt Mts, 12
Aug. 2001, Smook 11347 (PRE, WIND!); Diamond area
no. 1, Obib Mt. peak, 3 Sept. 1989, Van Wyk 9014 (PRE,
WIND); Huns Mts, 24 km up Letterklip R., 26 Sept.
1983, Walter 159 (WIND); Aus, Farm Plateau, on the
slopes of plateau, N of the farmhouse, 13 April 1953,
Walter & Walter 2575 (WIND!); Diamond Area 1, Tsaus
Mt. Oct. 1977, Wendt B/1 (WIND!); Diamond area 1,
Tsaus Spinnenberg, Oct. 1977, Wendt 8/2 (WIND!);
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
9488, Page 21 of 44
Fig. 5. Pteronia lucilioides. A habit; B leaf, abaxial; C capitulum; D phyllaries; E floret, side view; F floret, opened; G achene and
pappus; H achene; J pappus setae of mixed length. A – B, E Kolberg & Tholkes HK2049; C – D, F – J Dinter 8192. DRAWN BY JULIET
BEENTJE.
Narudous Poort (Anusi 73), between Aus and Rosh
Pinah, 30 Aug. 1989, Wittneben 8771 (PRE, WIND!);
Uitsig, 40 km from Witputz, 1 Sept. 1989, Zietsman 1892
(WIND!). SOUTH AFRICA. Northern Cape Prov: Klein
Namaqualand, R. II, Drège s.n. [2779] (P. lucilioides
holotype G-DC, isotype P-027210!).
HABITAT. Slopes, gorges, dry rivers and washes in dwarf
shrub savanna, dwarf shrubland, desert-dwarf shrub
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 22 of 44
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
in the Northern and Western Cape Provinces of South
Africa. Images of South African material were seen and it
seems highly likely that P. lucilioides and P. gymnocline are
conspecific, but this cannot be confirmed without seeing
more material. The variability of leaf indumentum
density in Namibia also points towards this assumption.
The sharply acute immature capitula are a constant
character in all Namibian and South African material
seen of P. lucilioides (Figs 4 & 5). Hutchinson & Phillips
(1917: 294) retained P. gymnocline DC. while they listed P.
gymnocline E. Mey. in Drege ("not of DC.") as synonym of
P. lucilioides together with P. bromoides S. Moore and P.
lucilioides var. sparsifolia Harv.
Map 12. Known distribution of Pteronia lucilioides in Namibia.
transition and steppe dominated by succulent species;
300 – 2000 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. This common and very widespread species has an estimated EOO and AOO well
above the threshold for any of the threatened
categories and no threats causing decline, fragmentation or fluctuation of populations could be identified
(IUCN 2013). The Namibian status thus is LC (IUCN
2001). The South African threat status is listed as LC
too (SANBI 2011).
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: February to October. Fruiting:
June to December.
NOTES. The species is near-endemic to Namibia with
the greater part of its distribution extending from the
Karibib area southwards to the Orange river with a few
localities south of this river in South Africa. The
specimens from the Karibib district (Dinter 6933 and
Seydel 1553) to the best of current knowledge must be
placed with Pteronia lucilioides, although this locality is
disjunct from the rest of the species’ range.
The collection Dinter 6933 in K carries the original
(Dinter) identification of Pteronia roesemanniana, a
Dinter manuscript name, which was re-determined
by Merxmüller as P. lucilioides.
The leaves of Pteronia lucilioides are densely papillose and the capitula typically sharply acute in bud. In
its range in southern Namibia P. lucilioides exhibits
considerable variability in growth form: nearer the
coast plants are low, much-branched shrublets, while
further inland they are mostly virgate, sparsely
branched shrubs which may be over 2 m tall. The
density of leaf indumentum also varies but leaves of
Namibian material were never completely glabrous.
Glabrous leaves are the main character that distinguishes this species from P. gymnocline DC. (de
Candolle 1836: 359). The latter is reported to occur
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
13. Pteronia mucronata DC. (de Candolle 1836: 362);
Harvey in Harvey & Sonder (1865: 106); Hutchinson &
Phillips (1917: 308); Merxmüller (1955: 80; 1967: 157);
Merxmüller & Roessler (1984: 90); Herman (2003:
278). Type: South Africa, Eastern Cape Prov., ZwartRuggens, Drège s.n. [2158] (holotype G-DC; isotype P027224!; other isotypes may exist — see Notes).
Pteronia dinteri S. Moore (1904: 1012); Dinter (1926:
132, “Dinteri”); Range (1935: 275, “Dinteri”). Type:
Namibia, Hereroland, Südrand der Etosapfanne
[Etoschapfanne], 23 July 1899, Dinter 739 (holotype
BM-001114680!; isotype Z-000052414!).
Pteronia mucronata DC. subsp. dinteri (S. Moore)
Merxm. (Merxmüller 1955: 80).
Shrub to 70 cm tall. Stems much-branched, short, glabrous,
grey to black, striate. Leaves opposite, clustered along
stems, dark green, surface glabrous or scattered white
bristly, linear, boat-shaped or somewhat keeled, to 8 × 1
mm; apex obtuse; base connate; margins white ciliate;
aromatic. Capitula solitary, terminal, narrowly cylindrical,
12 – 20 × 5 – 7 mm; apex rounded in bud; base acute.
Receptacle honeycombed. Phyllaries multiseriate, ovate to
oblong-linear, 3 – 10 mm long, bright yellow, shiny,
glabrous; midrib thickened towards apex and forming a
small, recurved mucro; apex truncate, slightly emarginate; margins jagged, ciliate. Florets c. 12 – 15; corollas to 10
mm long, sparsely glandular, yellow; lobes lanceolate,
subobtuse. Achenes obconical, densely villous, to 4 mm
long. Pappus c. 10 mm long, yellow.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Namibia, South Africa. Map 13.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Hardap Region,
Maltahöhe Distr.: Naukluft. Kapokvlakte on plateau,
1 Oct. 1995, Bridgeford 95359 (WIND!); Bergzebrapark
Naukluft MAL 9, 2 June 1968, Giess 10441 (WIND!);
Bergzebrapark Naukluft MAL 9, NW gorge, 3 Sept.
1972, Merxmüller & Giess 28191 (M, WIND!); Farm
Rooiberg-Süd, 1935, Steyn 9960 (WIND!); Rehoboth
Distr.: 23 km W along road D1261 from junction on
road C24 (NE of Nauchas), 28 Aug. 2009, Kolberg &
Tholkes HK2823 (K!, WIND!); Farm Narais North 245,
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
Map 13. Known distribution of Pteronia mucronata in
Namibia.
14 June 2004, Wittneben W04 248 (WIND!); Karas
Region, Bethanie Distr.: Farm Soutkuil, stock camp
before turning off to road to Bobbejaankranz, 22 Sept.
1989, Craven 3472 (WIND!); Fish R. Canyon, 10 Aug.
1976, Giess 14581 (PRE, WIND!); Fish R. Canyon, 10
Aug. 1976, Giess 14583 (WIND!); Farm Aruab 23, area
around Aris Post, 5 April 1998, Miller MIL1/ 49
(WIND!); Farm Aruab 23, S part of farm, April 1998,
Miller MIL1/ 088 (WIND!); Karasburg Distr.: Farm
Mooirivier, 1 Sept. 1997, Strohbach, Kubirske &
Sheuyange 2972 (WIND!); Keetmanshoop Distr.: Farm
Dassiefontein 87, E camp, 29 March 1998, Strohbach &
Dauth 3780 (WIND!); Lüderitz Distr.: Namuskluft,
Rosh Pinah, Aug. 2003, Bruyns 9847 (BOL, WIND!);
Farm Kolke LU 84, 4 Oct. 1975, Giess 13831 (PRE,
WIND!); Farm Piet-se-Puts LUS 77. Black limestone
gorge at the gate of farm Kanies LUS 71, Sept. 1976,
Giess & Wendt 14748 (WIND!); Farm Namuskluft 88,
20 Sept. 2003, Klaassen, Bartsch & Loots EK1204
(WIND!); Pockenbank, 15 – 20 km E of main road
against N boundary to Kokerboomkloof, 30 Oct. 2000,
Loots SL20 (WIND!); Farm Witpütz South, Aug. 1963,
Merxmüller & Giess 3213 (M, PRE, WIND!); Diamond
Area 1, centre of Tsausberg, Oct. 1977, Wendt 3/4
(WIND!); Diamond Area 1, Tsaus Spinnenberg, Oct.
1977, Wendt 15/2 (WIND!); Khomas Region, Windhoek Distr.: Weener farm, Gamsberg, on E side,
Craven 5111 (WIND!); Gurumanas REH 241, 29 Aug.
1972, Merxmüller & Giess 28073 (M, WIND!);
Weissenfels, 30 Aug. 1972, Merxmüller & Giess 28110
(M, PRE, WIND!); Farm Naos, 15 July 1953,
Schwerdtfeger 4350 (WIND!); Kunene Region, Outjo
Distr.: S edge of Etosha Pan, 23 July 1899, Dinter 739
(P. dinteri holotype BM-001114680!; isotype Z000052414!). SOUTH AFRICA. Eastern Cape Prov.:
Jansenville Div., Zwart-Ruggens, Aug. 1827, Drège s.n.
9488, Page 23 of 44
[2158] (P. mucronata holotype G-DC; isotype P027224!; potential isotypes HAL-0110982!, HBG505099!, HBG-503990!, K-000273457!, P-027225!, P027226!, P-027227!, PRE, SAM-0016168-0!, TUB005029!, W-0020461!, W-0008803!, W-Rchb.-18990219753!).
HABITAT. Mountains, hills and rocky outcrops of
dolomite or calcrete in dwarf shrub savanna, desertdwarf shrub transition, desert and steppe dominated
by succulent species; 1200 – 1800 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. Estimated EOO and AOO for
Pteronia mucronata in Namibia are above the maxima
that would qualify it for a threatened category (IUCN
2013). In addition, no threats that would cause
qualification under any of the five IUCN criteria were
established (IUCN 2013). The conservation status in
Namibia is therefore LC (IUCN 2001). The South
African threat status is recorded as LC (SANBI 2011).
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: June to October. Fruiting:
October to March.
VERNACULAR NAMES. Kersbossie (Afrikaans, South
Africa).
NOTES. The consistently ciliate leaf margins or keels
best distinguish Pteronia mucronata from P. unguiculata,
in addition to the fewer and smaller florets, achenes
and shorter pappus in the latter. Specimens with
sparsely ciliate margins can be mis-identified as P.
unguiculata also because the distribution areas overlap.
In Namibia P. mucronata is confined to higher altitudes
of the south-west and the central highlands. However,
the type specimen of P. dinteri, Dinter 739, even though
its locality on the “southern edge of the Etosha pan”
covers a large area (and was therefore not indicated
on Map 13), does not conform to this. This area in the
central north of Namibia is only around 1100 m above
sea level without any high mountains (1200 – 1800 m
high mountains is more typical of the mucronata
distribution) although it has calcareous and/or saline
soils. The vegetation on the fringes of the Etosha pan
consists of dwarf shrubs, which is, together with the
soils, comparable to the habitat of P. mucronata. The
closest records of P. mucronata (Map 13) are in the
central highlands, approximately 500 km due south of
the Etosha pan; on the other hand a disjunct locality
of P. unguiculata (see distribution on Map 23) at the
Brandberg is only about 250 km SW thereof. Dinter 739
has clearly pectinate leaves though, which place it into
P. mucronata even though P. unguiculata would make
more sense from a phytogeographical perspective.
Because of differences in number of florets (12 – 15
in P. mucronata; c. 5 in P. dinteri), capitula length (P.
mucronata: 15 – 20 mm; P. dinteri: 10 – 14 mm) and
pappus length (P. mucronata: 10 mm; P. dinteri: 7 mm),
Merxmüller (1955) did not agree with the sinking of P.
dinteri into P. mucronata by Hutchinson & Phillips
(1917: 308) and kept it as a subspecies, which would
support the odd distribution of this specimen. He later
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 24 of 44
(Merxmüller 1967), however, included both P. dinteri
and P. mucronata subsp. dinteri under P. mucronata. No
other species of Pteronia besides the clearly different P.
eenii has been found in the area directly south of the
Etosha pan. A thorough investigation of this extensive
area would be needed to confirm the presence of any
other species of Pteronia, especially of P. mucronata, to
better assess the anomaly of the Dinter 739 location.
At his locality II c 4 “Zwart-Ruggens, Karroofläche,
2000 – 3000 Fuss, August” Drège (1843: 61) lists Pteronia
mucronata. Parts, or all, of this locality data is found in
association with many potential isotypes that all lack a
reference to the de Candolle number “[2158]” — for
example HAL-0110982, HBG-503990, HBG-505099, K000273457, P-027225, P-027226, P-027227, PRE, SAM0016168-0, TUB-005029, W-0020461, W-Rchb.-18990219753. Similar to other cases, those presented with
the year “1837” are also excluded (for example K000273458 and W-0008803, the latter actually indicated
as an isotype by W) as it is uncertain if this is a collection
date or a herbarium dispatch or receipt date.
14. Pteronia onobromoides DC. (de Candolle 1836: 364);
Harvey in Harvey & Sonder (1865: 109); Hutchinson &
Phillips (1917: 299); Dinter (1931: 167); Range (1935:
276); Merxmüller (1967: 157); Merxmüller & Roessler
(1984: 90); Herman (2003: 278). Type: South Africa,
Western Cape Prov., Olifantrivier W (of “West”?), Drège
s.n. [5660] (lectotype G-DC, no. G-00322353!, selected
here; isolectotype P-027233! (sub nom. P. mucronata but
with “Ebenezar” and [5660] added); other isolectotypes
may exist — see Notes).
Shrub, to 50 cm tall. Stems glabrous, smooth, pale greywhite. Leaves alternate, glabrous, flat, linear-oblong,
distinctly 1- veined beneath, to 20 – 40 × 3 – 5 mm; apex
obtuse or subacute; base truncate; margins stiffly white
ciliate. Capitula solitary, terminal, obconical, 35 × 15 – 25
mm. Receptacle honeycombed and fimbriate. Phyllaries
multiseriate, gradate, orbicular to ovate to linear-oblong
(inner), to 8 mm long, greenish, glabrous, coriaceous;
without midrib; apex truncate or obtuse; margins
coriaceous. Florets c. 15; corollas to 20 mm long, glabrous,
yellow; lobes linear-lanceolate, acute; tube slender,
ribbed. Achenes compressed oblanceolate, densely golden sessile glandular, not hairy, to 7 mm long. Pappus
multiseriate, barbellate, to 15 mm long, golden-brown.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Namibia, South Africa. Map 14.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Karas Region, Lüderitz
Distr.: Oranjemund, slopes towards diamond mine, 24
March 1958, Merxmüller & Giess 2326 (M, PRE,
WIND!). SOUTH AFRICA. Western Cape Prov.:
Olifantrivier W (of “West”?), Drège s.n. [5660] (P.
onobromoides lectotype G-DC, no. G-00322353!;
isolectotype P-027233!; possible isolectotypes: HAL© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
Map 14. Known distribution of Pteronia onobromoides in
Namibia.
0110983!, HBG-505195!, K000273445!, TUB-005030!,
W-Rchb.-1889-0219717!, W-Rchb.-1889-0278273!).
Northern Cape Prov.: Namaqualand, Ecklon 31 (P.
onobromoides syntype G-DC no. G-00322351!); Ecklon 73
(P. onobromoides syntype G-DC no. G-00322352!).
HABITAT. Sandy slopes, coastal steppe dominated by
succulent species; no altitudinal data are present on
the examined collections.
CONSERVATION STATUS. The South African threat
status is Least Concern (LC) (SANBI 2011). There
are very few collections from Namibia, suggesting that
it is rare but the limited information available does not
allow an evaluation at this stage, and it must be
assigned Data Deficient (DD) status in Namibia
(IUCN 2001).
PHENOLOGY. Fruiting: March.
NOTES. This coastal species has been collected only
twice in Namibia (only one of which was seen by us),
likely caused by being in the access-restricted diamond
mining area in the south-west of the country. Elsewhere it is common along the coast of the Northern
and Western Cape Provinces of South Africa.
De Candolle (1836: 364) lists two locations with
collectors: “in Africa Capensi ad Olifant-rivier (Dreg.!)
et in Namaqualand (Eckl.!).”. Inspection in G-DC
revealed that there are three collections involved
(mounted together on a single sheet), one by Drège
with the associated number [5660], and two by
Ecklon, nos 31 and 73. These are all of comparable
quality, but our research showed that only of the
Drège one there is the (distinct) possibility that it has
been distributed to other herbaria. Only for this
reason we have selected the Drège collection as the
lectotype. The enumeration of 1843 shows that Drège
collected Pteronia onobromoides at locality III E a 4,
which is Ebenezar and located on the Olifant River,
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
9488, Page 25 of 44
and it seems reasonable to assume a copy of this
gathering was seen by de Candolle. Some possible
isolectotypes are the Drège specimens in HAL, HBG,
K, TUB and W-Rchb., which are annotated with the
locality "Ebenezar" and the code III E a 4, though
none carries [5660], which would have demonstrated
a more direct link with the G-DC lectotype. Ecklon 31
and 73 in G-DC are now the remaining syntypes.
15. Pteronia paniculata Thunb. (Thunberg 1800: 143);
de Candolle (1836: 365); Harvey in Harvey & Sonder
(1865: 102); Hutchinson & Phillips (1917: 312); Dinter
(1931: 168); Merxmüller (1967: 157); Merxmüller &
Roessler (1984: 90); Herman (2003: 278). Type: South
Africa, Western Cape Prov., Cape of Good Hope,
Thunberg s.n. (holotype UPS-THUNB).
Pteronia flexicaulis auct. non L. f.: de Candolle (1836:
360).
Shrub, to 50 cm tall. Stems glabrous, grey. Leaves opposite,
clustered along stems, fleshy, lacquered, viscid, bright
green, glabrous, linear, terete to boat-shaped, to 15 – 25 ×
Fig. 6. Fruiting Pteronia paniculata.
1 – 2 mm; apex recurved, subobtuse; base connate,
forming a c. 5 mm long sheath. Capitula in dense terminal
cymes, cylindrical to narrowly turbinate, 10 × 3 – 4 mm;
apex obtuse in bud. Receptacle honeycombed, remains
long after seed is shed, conspicuous. Phyllaries
multiseriate, ovate-oblong to oblanceolate, 3 – 8 × 1 – 2
mm, lime-yellow, glabrous, lacquered; apex obtuse;
without conspicuous membranous margins. Florets to 4;
corollas to 5 mm long, glabrous, yellow; lobes lanceolate,
subacute; tube ribbed. Achenes compressed obovoid,
contracted terminally, long villous, to 2.5 mm long. Pappus
bi-seriate, bristles broadened at base, scale-like, c. 4 mm
long, white to golden. Fig. 6.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Namibia, South Africa. Map 15.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Karas Region, Lüderitz
Distr.: Diamond Area 1, Skorpion, 27 Aug. 1997, Burke
97208 (WIND!); Kovis Mts, 32 km (20 miles) E of
Lüderitz, on the Lüderitz – Aus road, 6 March 1963,
De Winter & Hardy 7912 (PRE, WIND!); Aus, 21 Oct.
1922, Dinter 4147 (Z!); Farm Klein Aus, W of Aus, 9
Aug. 1959, Giess & Van Vuuren 932 (PRE, WIND!);
Rocky gorge just as you exit Klinghardt Mts, travelling
PHOTO: H. KOLBERG.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 26 of 44
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
Merxmüller (1955: 80, 1967: 157); Merxmüller &
Roessler (1984: 90); Herman (2003: 278). Type: Namibia, Gross Namaland, Gubub [Kubub], südöstlich von
Aus, Schenck 147 (holotype Z-000003817!).
Pteronia quinquecostata Dinter (1932: 183). Type:
Namibia, Jakkalskuppe, 1 Nov. 1922, Dinter 4184
(holotype B†; isotype SAM-0071810-0!).
Pteronia kingesii Merxm. (Merxmüller 1952: 125). Type:
Namibia, Klein Aus, 27 June 1949, Kinges 2280
(holotype M-0104532!; isotype PRE).
Map 15. Known distribution of Pteronia paniculata in Namibia.
E, 11 Sept. 2005, Mannheimer CM2759 (WIND!); (Aus)
quartz foothills, 17 Sept. 2005, Mannheimer CM2821
(WIND!); Kovis Mts, E side, mostly at foot of mountain, 13 Sept. 1972, Merxmüller & Giess 28433 (M, PRE,
WIND!); Klinghardt Mts, S part near the Sargdeckel,
19 Sept. 1977, Merxmüller & Giess 32120 (M, WIND!);
Gabusib R., 18 Feb. 1992, Strohbach 72 (WIND!);
Boegoeberg, 28 Sept. 1992, Strohbach 219 (WIND!); S
Namib, Diamond Area no. 1, Aurus Mts (N), 21 April
1988, Ward & Seely 10238 (WIND!); Diamond Area no.
1, Rooiberg, Oct. 1977, Wendt 23/1 (WIND!).
HABITAT. In windblown sand on slopes, steppe dominated by succulents; 700 – 1400 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. Although this species' distribution in Namibia is fairly restricted, the estimated EOO
and AOO still exceed the threshold for threatened
categories (IUCN 2013). In addition no threats are
known that would cause population fragmentation,
decline or fluctuation to the extent that the species
would fall into any threatened category according to
criteria A to E of the IUCN system (IUCN 2001). The
Namibian conservation status is thus evaluated as LC.
The South African threat status is also listed as LC
(SANBI 2011).
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: August to October. Fruiting:
February to April (the exceptional four – six-month
period rather than the two – three months as would
normally be expected could be ascribed to the limited
Namibian data on which this assessment is based).
VERNACULAR NAMES. Gombossie (Afrikaans, South
Africa).
NOTES. In Namibia this species is restricted to the
extreme south-west, which receives winter rainfall.
16. Pteronia polygalifolia O. Hoffm. (Hoffmann 1893:
73); Dinter (1926: 132); Range (1935: 276);
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
Shrub, much branched, 80 cm tall. Stems scabrid, brittle,
pale grey, striate. Leaves opposite, soft, surface rough
papillate, glandular, flat, obovate, spathulate to orbicular, to 10 × 8 mm; apex rounded to subacute; base
narrowed into a short petiole. Capitula solitary, terminal,
cylindrical, 15 × 3 – 9 mm; apex acute in bud. Receptacle
slightly concave. Phyllaries multiseriate, gradate, lanceolate to oblong, to 5 × 2 mm, pale yellow, glabrous; apex
subacute; margins membranous. Florets 10 – 12; corollas c.
7 mm long, well exserted above phyllaries, pale yellow;
lobes linear-lanceolate, acute. Achenes compressed obovoid, glandular, long white villous, to 3 mm long.
Pappus setae basally connate, at most 8 mm long, white to
pale golden. Fig. 7.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: endemic to Namibia. Map 16.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Hardap Region,
Maltahöhe Distr.: Satanskop off farm Springbokvlakte
166, 23 July 1983, Craven 4218 (WIND!); Namibrand
Nature Reserve, 19 Sept. 1997, De Winter 10227
(WIND!); Farm Vreemdelingspoort 141, July 1971,
Logan 311 (WIND!); Karas Region, precise district
unknown: Gross Namaland, Oranje, 1880, Steingröver 1
(Z!); Bethanie Distr.: Mara farm 114, 11 July 1986,
Craven 2666 (WIND!); Lüderitz Distr.: Aus. Dikwillem,
31 July 2002, Bartsch SB873 (WIND!); Granite hills 3
km (1 mile) W of Aus, 11 Sept. 1958, De Winter & Giess
6261 (WIND!, PRE); Jakkalskuppe, 1 Nov. 1922, Dinter
4184 (P. quinquecostata isotype SAM-0071810-0!); Huns
Mts, S of farm Uitsig LU 82, state land, 9 June 1976, Giess
& Müller 14287 (WIND!, PRE); Aus (?), May 2005,
Greyling & Wolf CW 05-08 (WIND!); Klein Aus farm; on
slope of Zipfel hill, 27 June 1949, Kinges 2280 (P. kingesii
holotype M-0104532!; isotype PRE); Aus Municipal
campsite, 7 Aug. 2001, Klaassen & Bartsch EK523
(WIND!); Farm Klein Aus Vista, Geister Trail from cabin
in Geisterschlucht, rocky hill slopes to SW, 4 Oct. 2006,
Kolberg & Tholkes HK2051 (K!, WIND!); Farm Klein Aus
Vista, Geisterschlucht. Rocky gorge E of cabin, 20 Sept.
2007, Kolberg, Van Slageren, Tholkes & Whaley HK2347 (K!,
WIND!); Municipal campsite at Aus, 22 Sept. 2003,
Mannheimer CM2455 (WIND!); Koppie W of Aus, Sept.
2005, Mannheimer CM2832 (WIND!); Heinrichsfelde,
near koppie W of chalets, 29 July 2006, Mannheimer
CM3030 (WIND!); Aus, mts on Farm Klein Aus, 18 Aug.
1963, Merxmüller & Giess 2961 (M, WIND!); Kubub Mts S
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
Fig. 7. Fruiting Pteronia polygalifolia.
9488, Page 27 of 44
PHOTO: A. MCROBB, RBG KEW.
of Aus, 21 Aug. 1963, Merxmüller & Giess 3028 (M,
WIND!); Farm Eureka 49, 14 Sept. 1972, Merxmüller &
Giess 28449 (M, WIND!); Aus townlands, 10 Oct. 1979,
Owen Smith 1274 (WIND!); Great Namaland, Gubub
[Kubub], SE of Aus, 14 July 1885, Schenck 147 (P.
polygalifolia holotype Z-000003817!); Kubub, March
1885, Schinz 697 (Z!); Namib Desert Park. SW side of
Map 16. Known distribution of Pteronia polygalifolia in Namibia.
Hauchab Mts, approx. 100 m above base of outcrop, 19
Aug. 1980, Seely & Ward 26 (WIND!); Farm Neisip 34.
Aus, 10 June 1972, Wiss 2554 (WIND!).
HABITAT. Rocky slopes (mostly granite) in desert and
desert-dwarf shrub transition zone; 750 – 1650 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. Using the 1994 IUCN criteria,
Craven & Loots (2002) evaluated this species as Lower
Risk – Least Concern (LRlc). Using more recent criteria
(IUCN 2001) Pteronia polygalifolia is re-evaluated as LC
here because its estimated EOO and AOO are larger
than the maxima qualifying it for a threatened category.
No threats to the species are known that would cause
qualification under any of the other criteria in the IUCN
system (IUCN 2013). Since this is a Namibian endemic,
this is a global conservation status.
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: May to October. Fruiting:
September to December.
NOTES. This species has been recorded only in southwestern Namibia (Map 16).
17. Pteronia pomonae Merxm. (Merxmüller 1952: 127;
1967: 157); Merxmüller & Roessler (1984: 90); Herman
(2003: 278). Type: Namibia, Alicetal bei Pomona, 6
June 1929, Dinter 6412 (holotype M-0104533!;
isotypes B-10-0097214!, B-10-0097215!, HBG505135!, HBG-505187!, HBG-505188!, HBG© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 28 of 44
505189!, HBG-505191!, K-000273528!, PRE-01616310!, S-07-7260!, Z-000052428!).
Pteronia cancellata Dinter (1932: 184), nom. nud. — see
Notes.
Pteronia villosa auct. non L. f.: Dinter (1931: 169, author
as “L.”;1932: 184); Range (1935: 276, author as “L.”).
Shrub, much-branched, to 50 cm tall. Stems glabrous, pale
grey when young, dark grey and fissured when older. Leaves
alternate to almost opposite, clustered on dwarf shoots,
terminally with long, white marginal bristles forming cage
around capitula, lower leaves without bristles, glabrous,
linear, terete, 10 × 1 mm; apex obtuse; base slightly eared,
sessile, not connate. Capitula solitary, terminal, cylindrical
to ovoid, 8 – 10 × 4 – 5 mm; apex rounded in bud. Receptacle
fimbriate. Phyllaries multiseriate, narrowly oblong to elliptic,
2 – 3 × 5 – 10 mm, green to yellow, glabrous; apex rounded;
margins dark brown or red on outer and narrow hyaline on
inner phyllaries. Florets 9 – 12; corollas to 6 mm long, pilose,
bright yellow; lobes linear-lanceolate, acute; tube gradually
widening. Achenes turbinate compressed, densely sericeous,
glandular, to 2 mm long. Pappus setae connate at base, c. 4
mm long, golden. Fig. 8.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: endemic to Namibia. Map 17.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Karas Region, Lüderitz
Distr.: Diamond Area No. 1, Chamnaub Inselberg, NE
of Boegoeberg, 28 Aug. 2002, Bartsch SB929 (WIND!);
Diamond Area 1, Namitsis Inselberg, about 30 km S of
Klinghardts, 1 Sept. 2002, Bartsch, Loots & Mannheimer
SB947 (WIND!); Rote Kuppe – Chamais road, 6 Sept.
2002, Bartsch, Loots & Mannheimer SB1035 (WIND!);
Diamond Area 1, Klinghardt's Mts, 21 Sept. 1996,
Burke 96156 (WIND!); W side of Münzen Mts, 30 Aug.
1958, De Winter & Giess 6120 (PRE, WIND!); Gais area,
E of Hohenfels, on the road to Jakkalsberge,
Oranjemund, 4 Sept. 1958, De Winter & Giess 6199
(PRE, WIND!); Diamond area no 1, Oranjemund, Gais
area, E of Hohenfels, on the road to Jakkalsberge, 5
Sept. 1958, De Winter & Giess 6202 (WIND!); Coastal
desert on gneiss hills at Halenberg, 15 Oct. 1922,
Dinter 4086 (K!, PRE); Alicetal near Pomona, 6 June
1929, Dinter 6412 (P. pomonae holotype M-0104533!;
isotypes B-10-0097214!, B-10-0097215!, HBG-505135!,
HBG-505187!, HBG-505188!, HBG-505189!, HBG505191!, K-000273528!, PRE-0161631-0!, S-07-7260!, Z000052428!; P. cancellata vouchers B-10-0097214!, B-100097215!, E-00413376!, HBG-505135!, HBG-505187!,
HBG-505188!, K-000273528!, S-07-7260!, SAM0071825-0!, Z-000052428!); Klinghardt Mts, 31 Aug.
2002, Gess & Gess 02/03/28 (WIND!); Farm Witputz
Nord LU 22. 20.5 km SW of the police station, 30 Sept.
1975, Giess 13766 (PRE, WIND!); Farm Spitzkop LU
111, 14 Aug. 1976, Giess 14630 (PRE, WIND!);
Sperrgebiet, turn-off at N entrance to Klinghardt
Mts, 4 Aug. 2001, Klaassen & Bartsch EK466 (WIND!);
39 km from Rotkop on powerline track, low koppie, 22
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
Oct. 1987, Kolberg & Maggs HK194 (PRE, WIND!);
Kovis Mts, campsite, at base of mountain, SW of radio
mast, 8 Oct. 2006, Kolberg & Tholkes HK2079 (K!,
WIND!); Sperrgebiet, Lüderitz – Oranjemund road at
N turn-off to Bogenfels, 14 Oct. 2006, Kolberg & Tholkes
HK2098 (K!, WIND!); Close to the mainroad, 9 Sept.
2005, Kwembeya EKw57 (WIND!); Tafelberg, SE of
Klinghardt Mts, Sperrgebiet 1, Aug. 1971, Logan &
Jensen 902 (WIND!); Schwarzkop, NE of Bogenfels,
Sperrgebiet 1, Aug. 1971, Logan & Jensen 1093
(WIND!); Pietab 1, Klinghardt Mts, Sperrgebiet, Aug.
1971, Logan & Jensen 1137 (WIND!); Between
Chamnaib and Bogenfels, 29 Aug. 2002, Mannheimer
CM2046 (WIND!); Namitsas, S of Klinghardt Basin,
Sept. 2002, Mannheimer CM2095 (WIND!); E
Sperrgebiet, 2 Sept. 2002, Mannheimer CM2148
(WIND!); Road to Grillental from Kaukausib, 5 Sept.
2002, Mannheimer CM2202 (WIND!); 23 km S of
Grillental, 12 Sept. 1972, Merxmüller & Giess 28381 (M,
PRE, WIND!); 9.5 km S of Grillental, 15 Sept. 1977,
Merxmüller & Giess 32019 (M, PRE, WIND!); Klinghardt
Mts, in the S part, in the region of Sargdeckel, 17 Sept.
1977, Merxmüller & Giess 32110 (M, WIND!); Klinghardt
Mts, near the foot of the mountain, 28 July 1977, Müller
696 (WIND!); Sperrgebiet, hills on N side of Klinghardt
Mts, 13 Aug. 2001, Smook 11374 (PRE, WIND!); Diamond
area no. 1, c. 18 km W of Rosh Pinah, towards Obib Mt, 1
Sept. 1989, Van Wyk 8890 (PRE, WIND!); S Namib,
Diamond area no. 1, S of Klinghardt Mt, 21 April 1988,
Ward & Seely 10233 (WIND!); Diamond Area 1, Tsaus
Spinnenberg, Oct. 1977, Wendt 8/1 (WIND!).
HABITAT. Plains and slopes in steppe characterised by
succulents; 200 – 700 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. Present information leads to
an evaluation of LC (IUCN 2001) for this relatively
abundant species. Both estimated EOO and AOO
are well above the thresholds for threatened categories and no population decline, fragmentation or
fluctuation could be identified that would qualify
this species as threatened (IUCN 2013). Pteronia
pomonae is endemic to Namibia and is LC thus the
global status.
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: July to October. Fruiting:
October to January.
NOTES. The characteristic long ciliate leaves at the base
of capitula make this Namibian endemic species easily
recognisable amongst Pteronia species in the country
(Fig. 8).
Pteronia cancellata is a manuscript name (Dinter
1932: 184) associated with Dinter 6412, now the type
of P. pomonae, and found on vouchers in (at least)
B, E, HBG, K, S, SAM, and Z, as follows: B-100097214!, B-10-0097215!, E-00413376!, HBG505135!, HBG-505187!, HBG-505188!, K000273528!, S-07-7260!, SAM-0071825-0!, and Z000052428!. Of these vouchers E and SAM do not
present a reference to P. pomonae on the sheet,
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
9488, Page 29 of 44
Fig. 8. Pteronia pomonae. A habit; B (upper) leaf, abaxial; C (upper) leaf, adaxial; D capitulum, side view; E (1 – 5) phyllaries, left to
right: outer to inner; F floret, side view; G corolla, opened and stamens; H style; J (young) achene with pappus; K pappus setae
detail. A – K Kolberg & Tholkes HK2098. DRAWN BY JULIET BEENTJE.
while all others do. Rather than describing and
adopting the name cancellata, Merxmüller (1952)
chose to ignore the epithet and replace it with
pomonae.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 30 of 44
Map 17. Known distribution of Pteronia pomonae in Namibia.
18. Pteronia quadrifaria Dinter (1932: 182). Type:
Namibia, Gross Namaland, Zwartaus, 17 March 1929,
Dinter 6190 (holotype B†; lectotype HBG-505185!,
selected here; isolectotype HBG-505186!).
Erect, intricately branched shrub, to 25 cm tall. Stems
pale tan or pale grey, lower layers white, farinose, bark
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
on older stems dark grey, longitudinally fissured, leaf
scars conspicuous, spiny remains of parts connecting
opposite leaves most conspicuous near branch tips.
Leaves decussate-imbricate, densely arranged at branch
tips, less imbricate on flowering branches, dehiscent at
base of branches, somewhat fleshy, surface minutely
papillose, margins ciliate-pectinate, more so towards leaf
apex, sometimes abaxial keel pectinate at apex, narrowly
oblong to linear-lanceolate, apex obtuse, boat-shaped,
convex beneath, midrib indented on slightly concave
adaxial surface, 4 – 5 × 1 – 1.5 mm; apex obtuse; base
sessile, somewhat connate, with spinules between bases of
opposite leaves. Capitula solitary, terminal, obconical to
ovoid, 10 – 12 × 4 – 6 mm; apex constricted, truncate in
bud. Receptacle epaleate. Phyllaries multiseriate, gradate,
spirally arranged, c. 20 per capitulum, oblong, 3 × 1.5 mm
to 10 × 1 mm, pale yellow-green, shiny, papillose towards
apex on abaxial surface; apex of outer acute, of inner
truncate; margins undulate, membranous and reflexed
at right angles. Florets 5 – 6; corollas 6.5 – 7 × 1 mm, short
papillate at area where translucent part meets
opaque part, pale yellow; lobes narrowly acute, short
bristly on outer surface; tube gradually widening
towards apex, basal third translucent, rest opaque.
Stamens 5, filaments fused to base of corolla. Anthers
fused into a tube, about half as long as stamens,
bases shortly sagittate, tips acute. Style bifid, branches
acute, half the length of style; stigmatic papillae
short. Ovary obconical to obtrigonous, densely cov-
Fig. 9. Pteronia quadrifaria showing the reflexed, undulate phyllaries, maroon pappus and densely imbricate, decussate leaves.
PHOTO: H. KOLBERG.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
ered with pale yellow, spherical, sessile glands,
densely hirsute. Achenes compressed obconical,
9488, Page 31 of 44
densely long, white hirsute and densely covered with
golden, spherical, sessile glands, 4.5 – 5 × 2 – 2.5 mm.
Fig. 10. Pteronia quadrifaria. A habit; B detailed positions of leaves; C leaf; D capitulum; E (1 – 7) sample of phyllaries; F side view
of floret and (young) achene; G floret, side view; H corolla tube, opened; J stamen; K style; L style branches; M young achene; N
pappus setae (three lengths). A – N Kolberg & Tholkes HK2893. DRAWN BY JULIET BEENTJE.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 32 of 44
Pappus setae fused at base into a ring, 4 – 8 mm long,
bristles barbellate, of different lengths, from half the
length of floret to longer than floret, maroon-purple.
Figs 9 – 10.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: endemic to Namibia. Map 18.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Karas Region, Lüderitz
Distr.: Zwartaus, 17 March 1929, Dinter 6190 (P. quadrifaria
lectotype HBG-505185!, isolectotype HBG-505186!); Aus,
hill N of Aus with NBC mast, below quartz ridge, 12 Oct.
2009, Kolberg & Tholkes HK2893 (K!, WIND!); Aus
townlands, white quartz hill with NBC mast, N of town,
13 Oct. 2010, Kolberg & Tholkes HK2994 (K!, WIND!).
HABITAT. Quartz or granite hills in steppe characterised
by a diversity of succulent species; c. 1600 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. A preliminary global conservation status of EN D1 can be assigned to this Namibian
endemic species because of the small number of
individuals found at the only site known (IUCN
2013). The population found recently was the first
one in Namibia since Dinter’s 1929 collection, and
consists of about 50 – 70 old plants on white quartz
with an estimated EOO well below 100 km2 and an
AOO smaller than 10 km2. No young plants were seen.
The species was not found on other hills with similar
substrate in the Aus vicinity. At the same time no
visible or increasing threat to the population could be
observed. Dinter (1932), however, reported having
found this species on granite of which there are
many hills in the Aus area that still need to be
investigated. Until the possible distribution area is
searched more closely for further populations of
this species, no final assessment of the conservation
status can be made.
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: October. Fruiting: December.
NOTES. Dinter (1932: 182) described Pteronia
quadrifaria from granite hills near Aus. The collected
material at the time was, by Dinter’s account, sterile
(Dinter 3580) or “with sterile heads” (Dinter 6190).
Indeed, both specimens at HBG have no intact
flowering parts. Dinter’s original collections were at
Berlin (Lanjouw & Stafleu 1954: 163) and are now
considered lost. Of the two syntypes Dinter 3580 was
not found anywhere else, but two specimens of 6190
were located at HBG, each with annotations in
Dinter’s handwriting; the collection HBG-505185,
being a bit more copious, is selected as the lectotype.
Pteronia quadrifaria was treated by Merxmüller
(1955) as a synonym of Pteronia lucilioides DC., based
mainly on the papillate leaves of the Dinter 6190
specimen. He argued that the growth form of P.
lucilioides is very variable in Namibia and that Dinter
6190 represents a densely branched, small, shrubby
form. Around Aus, however, P. lucilioides is a tall,
virgate shrub and the stunted dwarf shrub forms are
found mostly nearer to the coast. Based on recent
flowering and fruiting collections the differences
between the two species were confirmed, such as the
apex of the budding capitula that is constricted to
truncate in P. quadrifaria and sharply acute in P. lucilioides
(compare Figs 4 and 9). Furthermore the densely
imbricate, decussate leaf arrangement of P. quadrifaria
clearly differs from the opposite leaves of P. lucilioides, and
the undulate, reflexed phyllaries of the former differ from
the smooth, straight phyllaries of the latter. P. quadrifaria
can also be clearly distinguished from P. lucilioides by the
maroon-purple pappus (straw-coloured in the latter).
Reviewing all presented evidence we conclude that this
merits the resurrection of P. quadrifaria as a distinct entity.
Pteronia quadrifaria is similar to P. mucronata in its leaves
with ciliate margins and truncate phyllaries, but differs in
its decussate-imbricate leaf arrangement, its phyllary apex
not being mucronate but undulate-reflexed, and the
conspicuous maroon-purple pappus (Fig. 9).
19. Pteronia rangei Muschl. (Muschler 1911a: 96);
Hutchinson & Phillips (1917: 319); Dinter (1926: 132);
Range (1935: 276); Merxmüller (1952: 128; 1967: 158);
Merxmüller & Roessler (1984: 90); Herman (2003:
278). Type: Namibia, Bezirk von Gross Namaqualand,
Aus, Tafelberg, 1600 m, Oct. 1906, Range A 26
(holotype B†; lectotype BOL-138777!, selected here;
isolectotype K-000273503!).
Map 18. Known distribution of Pteronia quadrifaria in
Namibia.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
Shrub, to 60 cm tall. Stems glabrous, cream to pale grey,
leaf scars distinct. Leaves alternate, clustered along
stems, somewhat succulent, greyish-green, aromatic,
surface glabrous and tuberculate, linear, subterete,
curved towards stem, to 25 × 1 mm; apex obtuse; base
sessile, with tuft of hairs in axil. Capitula solitary,
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
9488, Page 33 of 44
Fig. 11. Pteronia rangei. A habit of branches; B branchlet with leaves; C capitulum, side view; D (left to right) phyllaries in outer,
mid, and inner position in capitulum, and an inner one viewed abaxially; E (left and right) floret side view with stamens (detail, left),
and overview from the side with stamens protruding (right); F floret side view with style branches; G corolla opened with stamens
and style (separate); H young achene with pappus; J achene detail; K pappus setae detail. A – K Kolberg & Tholkes HK2892. DRAWN
BY JULIET BEENTJE.
terminal, cylindrical to campanulate, elongate, to
15 × 10 mm; apex truncate in bud. Phyllaries
multiseriate, gradate, oblong-lanceolate to linearlanceolate, to 10 × 2 mm, green to yellow, glabrous;
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 34 of 44
midribs thickened, glandular, forming a recurved,
small mucro; apex subacute; margins membranous.
Florets c. 12; corollas to 8 mm long, yellow; lobes
linear lanceolate, subacute; tube contracted at
apex, strongly ribbed in lower half. Achenes oblong-cylindrical, appressed villous, to 3 mm long.
Pappus multiseriate, barbellate, c. 12 mm long, pale
yellow to golden brown. Fig. 11.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: endemic to Namibia. Map 19.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Karas Region,
Bethanie Distr.: Farm Kosos 11, 15 Aug. 1963,
Merxmüller & Giess 2817 (M, WIND!); Farm Saraus
BET 16, 5 Sept. 1972, Merxmüller & Giess 28227 (M,
WIND!); Keetmanshoop Distr.: Farm Lourensia, N of
homestead, 28 March 1998, Strohbach & Dauth 3764
(WIND!); Lüderitz Distr.: Kuibis, 2 Nov. 1922, Dinter
4181 (Z!); Farm Kolke LU 84, not far from the
farmhouse, 11 June 1976, Giess & Müller 14332
(WIND!); 70 km from Rotkop Station on power-line
track, W slope of mountains, 23 Oct. 1987, Kolberg &
Maggs HK208 (WIND!); Farm Zebrafontein, track
from road D463; at locked gate just before homestead,
20 Oct. 2007, Kolberg & Tholkes HK2411 (K!, WIND!);
21 km E along road D463 from Witpütz junction on
Aus – Rosh Pinah tar road, 12 Oct. 2009, Kolberg &
Tholkes HK2892 (K!, WIND!); Aus, Tafelberg, 1600
m, Oct. 1906, Range A 26 (P. rangei lectotype BOL138777!, isolectotype K-000273503!); Farm Plateau
38, on the slope of the ridges N of the farmhouse,
13 April 1953, Walter & Walter 2577 (WIND!).
HABITAT. Rocky slopes and plains of dwarf shrub
savanna, desert-dwarf shrub transition and steppe
dominated by succulent species; 1300 – 1400 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. Data Deficient (DD) according to Craven & Loots (2002) and Loots (2005).
During recent fieldwork the first author could not
identify any threats to populations and the species
is more abundant and widespread than the small
number of herbarium specimens would suggest. Reevaluation using IUCN (2001) criteria resulted in a
global LC status (Pteronia rangei is endemic to
Namibia) also because estimated EOO and AOO
are well above the thresholds for threatened status
(IUCN 2013).
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: June to October. Fruiting:
October to December.
NOTES. The tuberculate leaf surface is unique among
the Namibian species of Pteronia (Fig. 11). This
Namibian endemic has been recorded only in the
central south and south-west of the country (Map 19).
We have chosen a lectotype since the original
holotype in B is assumed lost. Isotypes were found only
in BOL and K. As the BOL isotype is of altogether better
quality, it is selected here as the lectotype. The
isolectotype in K (fragments only) notes (strung together
here): “flowers yellow, shrub, ½ m, Tafelberg 1600 m,
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
Oct. 06, Deutsch – Südwest Afrika, Dr. Range”, while
BOL has the altitude in feet (4800'). It should be
noted that none of the lectotype collections actually carries “Aus” as the locality, only “Tafelberg” —
of which there is one near Aus where the type was
collected at a place called Kubub. This is in
accordance with Paul Range’s handwritten list of
localities, seen by the first author.
20. Pteronia scariosa L. f. (Linnaeus filius 1782: 356);
Thunberg (1800: 144); de Candolle (1836: 361);
Harvey in Harvey & Sonder (1865: 104); Hutchinson
& Phillips (1917: 315); Dinter (1926: 132); Range
(1935: 276); Merxmüller (1952: 128; 1967: 158);
Merxmüller & Roessler (1984: 90); Herman (2003:
278). Type: South Africa, Western Cape Prov., Cape of
Good Hope, Thunberg s.n. (holotype UPS-THUNB;
isotype LD-1254325!).
Pteronia lycioides Muschl. ex Dinter (Dinter 1926: 132);
Range (1935: 275). Type: Namibia, Büllsporter
Fläche, Dinter 2146 (not traced, likely B†).
Shrub, to 50 cm tall. Stems glabrous, tan to greyish-brown,
tips somewhat spinescent. Leaves alternate, thickish,
coriaceous, glabrous, obovate to oblong-lanceolate, to
10 × 3 mm; apex rounded to subacute; base cuneate.
Capitula solitary, terminal, subcampanulate, to 20 × 18
mm; apex acute in bud. Receptacle flat, surface slightly
jagged. Phyllaries multiseriate, gradate, outer much
smaller than inner, broadly lanceolate, keeled, 3.5 × 2
mm to 15 × 4 mm, pale reddish-brown, membranous,
translucent, glabrous; midrib narrow, brown, extending into a sharp point; apex mucronate, acute;
margins finely lacerate. Florets c. 14; corollas to 2.5
mm long, yellow; lobes linear-lanceolate, subacute,
margins reddish-brown when dry; tube cylindric, 5ribbed near base. Achenes obovoid, contracted into
a short, glabrous neck, long villous, to 4 mm long.
Pappus setae fused into a basal ring, to 13 mm
long, brown to reddish-brown.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Namibia, South Africa. Map 20.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Hardap Region,
Maltahöhe Distr.: Büllsporter Fläche, 20 Sept. 1947,
Strey 2130 (NBG!, PRE); Khomas Region, Windhoek
Distr.: Farm Göllschau, 19 Nov. 1934, Dinter 7980 (P!,
WIND!). SOUTH AFRICA. Western Cape Prov.:
Zilverfontein, 25 Oct. 1830, Drège s.n. (HBG-505184!,
K-000273490!, P-027261!); Cape of Good Hope,
Thunberg s.n. (P. scariosa holotype UPS-THUNB,
isotype LD-1254325!).
HABITAT. Seasonally flooded plain in dwarf shrub
savanna.
CONSERVATION STATUS. This species has restricted
distribution (small estimated EOO and AOO) and
small number of populations in Namibia but no
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
9488, Page 35 of 44
Map 19. Known distribution of Pteronia rangei in Namibia.
Map 20. Known distribution of Pteronia scariosa in Namibia.
specific threats are known from the area of distribution. However, Pteronia scariosa has not been collected
in Namibia in the past 65 years and no specific efforts
were made to find it. Because of the lack of sufficient
recent data, the Namibian status is DD (IUCN 2001,
2013). Existing herbarium collections suggest that it is
rare in Namibia. The South African threat status has
been recorded as LC (SANBI 2011).
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: September to November.
NOTES. Only three specimens are known from Namibia, of which Dinter 2146 could not be traced (it was
undoubtedly in B and is now considered lost), and the
species has not been collected since 1947. The
Namibian population is disjunct from the distribution
of the species in South Africa’s Northern and Western
Cape Provinces. More material needs to be collected
in Namibia. The chances of plants still being at the
recorded localities are good, since these are in
relatively protected commercial farmland that has
been utilised sustainably.
opposite, glabrous or minutely puberulous, linear to
linear-lanceolate, boat-shaped, to 6 × 2 mm; apex obtuse;
bases somewhat fused. Capitula solitary, terminal,
obconical, base narrow, 15 × 10 – 12 mm; apex subacute
to truncate in bud. Receptacle fimbriate. Phyllaries
multiseriate, oblong-oblanceolate, closely imbricate,
to 10 × 3 mm, greenish-yellow, glabrous; midrib dark
greyish-green; apex acute to obtuse; lateral margins
membranous. Florets 5 – 9; corollas to 12 mm long,
yellow; lobes lanceolate, subacute; tube contracted
near base. Achenes oblong, densely villous, to 3.5 mm
long. Pappus multiseriate, 8 – 9 mm long, golden to
straw-coloured.
21. Pteronia sordida N. E. Br. (Brown 1906: 108);
Hutchinson & Phillips (1917: 325); Merxmüller (1955:
80, 1967: 158); Merxmüller & Roessler (1984: 90);
Herman (2003: 278). Type: South Africa, Eastern Cape
Prov., Conway Farm, Middelburg Div., 1100 m, Aug.
1899, Gilfillan in herb. Galpin 5527 (holotype K000273517!; isotype PRE-161726-0).
Pteronia chlorolepis Dinter (1932: 181). Type: Namibia,
Gross Namaland, Aus, 26 Oct. 1922, Dinter 4153
(lectotype HBG-505115!, selected here; isolectotypes
SAM-0071816-0!, Z-000003813!). — see Notes.
Pteronia glomerata auct. non L. f.: Range (1935: 275).
Shrub to 35 cm tall. Stems mostly glabrous, sometimes
whitish pubescent, older bark grey, fissured. Leaves
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Namibia, South Africa. Map 21.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Hardap Region,
Rehoboth Distr.: 23 km W along road D1261 from
junction with road C24 (NE of Nauchas), 28 Aug.
2009, Kolberg & Tholkes HK2824 (K!, WIND!); Karas
Region, Bethanie Distr.: 28 km S of Helmeringhausen
on road to Aus, 3 Oct. 2006, Kolberg & Tholkes HK2042
(K!, WIND!); Tirasberge, 16 Aug. 1963, Merxmüller &
Giess 2866 (M, WIND!); Lüderitz Distr.: Aus, 26 Oct.
1922, Dinter 4153 (P. chlorolepis lectotype HBG-505115!;
isolectotypes SAM-0071816-0!, Z-000003813!); Aus
townlands, S of town, 3 Oct. 2006, Kolberg & Tholkes
HK2045 (K!, WIND!); Farm Witpütz Süd, about 5 km
NE of house, calcrete ridges E of track to road D463,
25 Oct. 2007, Kolberg & Tholkes HK2443 (K!, WIND!);
Aus, at river on road to Helmeringhausen, 7 Aug.
1963, Merxmüller & Giess 2917 (M, PRE, WIND!); Farm
Plateau, 20 Aug. 1963, Merxmüller & Giess 3014 (M,
WIND!); Gross Namaland, Farm Plateau at
Schakalskuppe station, 13 April 1953, Walter & Walter
2558 (WIND!); Farm Plateau near Aus, 9 Sept. 1963,
Wiss 2021 (WIND!). SOUTH AFRICA. Eastern Cape Prov.:
Conway Farm, Middelburg Div., Aug. 1899, Gilfillan in
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 36 of 44
herb. Galpin 5527 (P. sordida holotype K-000273517!;
isotype PRE-161726-0).
HABITAT. Gravelly and rocky hills and plains in desert,
desert-dwarf shrub transition and dwarf shrub savanna; 1200 – 1650 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. In Namibia the estimated EOO
and AOO (22,500 km2 and 2,500 km2 respectively) just
exceed the maximum for the VU category under criterion
B (IUCN 2013). Pteronia sordida is known from only four
localities in Namibia, which would qualify it for a VU status
under criterion D2, but the necessary additional criteria
for threatened status (plausible threat, population
decline, fragmentation or fluctuation) are not
established (IUCN 2001, 2013). This results in a status of
LC in Namibia, the same as in South Africa (SANBI 2011).
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: April to September. Fruiting:
August to November.
NOTES. The distribution is disjunct in Namibia with
populations along the south-western escarpment and
one record from central Namibia. The Namibian
populations are in turn disjunct from the South
African ones in the Northern, Western and Eastern
Cape Provinces. The Namibian distribution can be
explained by the species’ preference for higher
altitudes but more material is needed to confirm this.
The HBG sheet of Dinter 4153 is chosen as the
lectotype of Pteronia chlorolepis since it is marginally
more informative than the other two extant duplicates
seen. The other syntype associated with the name
(Gross Namaland, Aus, 7 April 1929, Dinter 6259), was
probably only present in B and is now considered lost.
22. Pteronia spinulosa E. Phillips in Hutchinson & Phillips
(1917: 320); Merxmüller (1967: 158); Merxmüller &
Roessler (1984: 90); Herman (2003: 279). Type: Namibia,
Map 21. Known distribution of Pteronia sordida in Namibia.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
Angra Pequena [Lüderitzbucht], 18 January 1907,
Galpin & Pearson 7645 (lectotype SAM-0001648-0!,
selected here; isolectotypes BOL-138778!, K-000273506!,
PRE-0160582-0!).
Shrub, to 40 cm tall. Stems with rows of spinules where leaf
connections remain, glabrous, glaucous-grey. Leaves opposite, clustered along stems, slightly succulent, glabrous but
densely warty when dry, linear, boat-shaped to trigonous,
keeled, to 12 × 4 mm; apex obtuse; base connate. Capitula
solitary, terminal, oblong-ovoid, 12 – 15 × 6 – 7 mm; apex
subacute in bud. Receptacle deeply honeycombed, fimbriate.
Phyllaries multiseriate, oblong, closely imbricate, 2 – 10 mm
long, bright yellow, glabrous; midrib with oblong thickening; apex rounded; margins not obviously membranous.
Florets to 10; corollas to 6.5 mm long, glabrous, bright yellow;
lobes narrowly triangular, subobtuse. Achenes obovoid, long
appressed villous, 3 – 4 mm long. Pappus c. 5 mm long,
straw-coloured. Figs 12 – 13.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: endemic to Namibia. Map 22.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Karas Region, Lüderitz
Distr.: Diamond Area 1, Chameis, 22 Aug. 1997, Burke
97169 (WIND!); Bogenfels, 5 Sept. 1958, De Winter &
Giess 6216 (NBG, PRE, WIND!); Lüderitzbucht, Jan.
1929, Dinter 5994 (Z!); Lüderitzbucht, 18 Jan. 1907,
Galpin & Pearson 7645 (P. spinulosa lectotype SAM0001648-0!; isolectotypes BOL-138778!, K-000273506!,
PRE-0160582-0!); Spencer Bay – Nordhuk, 12 Jan.
1974, Giess & Robinson 13192 (PRE, WIND!);
Sperrgebiet, Pomona, road to house, 3 Aug. 2001,
Klaassen & Bartsch EK460 (WIND!); Lüderitz peninsula, Mesemb Bay, 10 Oct. 2006, Kolberg & Tholkes
HK2091 (K!, WIND!); Sperrgebiet, Granitberg Station,
N of Bogenfels, N of old mine dumps, 17 Feb. 2007,
Kolberg & Tholkes HK2199 (K!, WIND!); Lüderitzbucht,
Nov. 1908, Marloth 4621 (GRA-0002940-0!, PRE0160583-0!); Lüderitzbucht, on rocky terrain towards
Sturmvogelbucht, 21 March 1958, Merxmüller & Giess
2246 (M, PRE, WIND!); Nautilus, N Lüderitz, 23 Aug.
1963, Merxmüller & Giess 3075 (M, WIND!); Bogenfels,
9 Sept. 1972, Merxmüller & Giess 28327 (M, PRE,
WIND!); Valley W of Elizabeth Bay, June 1993,
Williamson 4543 (WIND!).
HABITAT. Gravelly or rocky plains and hill slopes with
windblown sand in desert and coastal steppe characterised
by a diversity of succulent species; 50 – 950 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. This species is restricted almost
entirely to the protected diamond mining area, now a
national park. Although Pteronia spinulosa is found
mostly close to the coast where mining activities are
also concentrated, a significant threat that would
cause population reduction has not been identified.
Mining here also underlies a sound environmental
management policy that would control future
threats. The estimated EOO and AOO and population sizes and number of locations are well above
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
the threshold for the threatened categories (IUCN
2001, 2013). The conservation status was assessed by
Loots (2005) as LC using IUCN (2001) criteria. This is a
Namibian endemic and the status thus global.
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: August to October. Fruiting:
December to March.
NOTES. Edwin Phillips (in Hutchinson & Phillips 1917)
listed Galpin & Pearson 7645 and Marloth 4621, these
together being the syntypes of Pteronia spinulosa. The
collections are equal in terms of quality and documentation, preventing an obvious choice between them for a
lectotype. It appears, however, that the Galpin & Pearson
specimen is more widely distributed than the Marloth
one, and is therefore chosen as the lectotype. Since
Phillips worked at the South African Museum at the time
of publishing this species, the Galpin & Pearson specimen
at SAM is selected as lectotype among the four existing
specimens. Marloth 4621 from Angra Pequena
[Lüderitzbucht] remains the other syntype.
This coastal species is endemic to Namibia
(Map 22). The spinules that remain after leaf dehiscence can best be seen on younger twigs because they
wear off on older branches (Figs 12 & 13).
23. Pteronia unguiculata S. Moore (1904: 1012);
Hutchinson & Phillips (1917: 326); Dinter (1926:
133); Range (1935: 276); Merxmüller (1967: 158);
Merxmüller & Roessler (1984: 90); Herman (2003:
279). Type: Namibia, Gross Namaland, Gubub
9488, Page 37 of 44
[Kubub], July 1897, Dinter 1233 (holotype BM001114681!, isotype Z-000003820!).
Shrub, to 100 cm tall, much-branched. Stems glabrous,
pale grey to grey-brown. Leaves opposite, clustered along
stems, glabrous, linear to clavate, terete, to 10 × 1 mm;
apex obtuse; base slightly eared, sessile. Capitula solitary,
terminal, elongate-cylindrical, 15 × 8 mm; apex obtuse in
bud. Phyllaries multiseriate, broadly obovate to elliptic,
broadest at apex, slightly contracted below apex, 7 – 9 × 5
mm, bright yellow, glabrous; apex truncate,
mucronulate, often emarginate; margins entire, at most
indistinctly lacerate-ciliate. Florets c. 10; corollas to 5 mm
long, glabrous, bright yellow; lobes narrlowly lanceolate.
Achenes turbinate, long sericeous, with few sessile glands,
to 3 mm long. Pappus c. 5 mm long, pale yellow. Fig. 14.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Namibia, South Africa. Map 23.
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. NAMIBIA. Erongo Region,
Omaruru Distr.: Brandberg, Amis Kloof, Sept. 1979,
Craven 1097 (WIND!); Brandberg, near Horn on the
higher plains on NW Brandberg, 19 July 1984, Craven
1883 (WIND!); Brandberg, upper reaches of
Königstein, 6 May 1993, Craven 4009 (WIND!); Hardap
Region, Maltahöhe Distr.: Namib Naukluft Park,
Naukluft Plateau, 6 July 1993, Bridgeford 141 (WIND!);
E facing path up Losberg to “repeater” (a telecoms
mast) in the Namibrand Nature Reserve, 1 July 2004,
Clapham & Drayer 149 (WIND!); Farm Mooirivier 169,
2 Sept. 1978, Horn 31 (WIND!); (Naukluft park)
Fig. 12. Horizontal-spreading branches of Pteronia spinulosa with fruiting capitula just prior to releasing achenes.
PHOTO: H. KOLBERG.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 38 of 44
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
Fig. 13. Pteronia spinulosa. A habit; B leaf, side view; C leaf showing fleshy adaxial surface; D detail of “spinules” (remnants after
pair of leaves drop off); E capitulum; F capitulum with most phyllaries removed; G range of phyllaries; H budding floret, side view; J
floret, side view; K style branches, detail; L young achene with pappus; M pappus setae, detail. A – M Kolberg & Tholkes HK2199.
DRAWN BY JULIET BEENTJE.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
9488, Page 39 of 44
Map 22. Known distribution of Pteronia spinulosa in Namibia.
Tweelingpan No. 9, 9 April 1971, Meyer 500 987
(WIND!); Losberg on the NRNR. (Namibrand Nature
Reserve), 6 Oct. 2001, Rahn 36 (WIND!);
Bergzebrapark-Naukluft, 20 June 1968, Van der
Fig. 14. Flowering Pteronia unguiculata branches.
Map 23. Known distribution of Pteronia unguiculata in
Namibia.
Westhuizen 3 (WIND!); Farm Naudaus/Duwisib MAL
76/84, 20 May 1956, Volk 12756 (WIND!); Farm
Maguams-Krähwinkel, Helmeringhausen, 23 March
PHOTO: I. DINTER.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 40 of 44
1953, Walter & Walter 2141 (WIND!); Rehoboth Distr.:
Springbokvlakte (Farm Nauzerus), 1 Nov. 1997,
Bührmann & Bührmann BUH1/13 (WIND!); Quartz
dyke, Bastardland, Nov. 1934, Dinter 8045 (Z!); Karas
Region, Bethanie Distr.: 38 km (23.5 miles) N of
Helmeringhausen, 19 Oct. 1949, Acocks 15634 (PRE,
WIND!); Farm Kosos, Helmeringhausen, Aug. 1963,
Merxmüller & Giess 2818 (M, WIND!); Farm Saraus
(BET 16), 5 Sept. 1972, Merxmüller & Giess 28228 (M,
PRE, WIND!); Rolling hills on Farm Aruab 23, July
1998, Miller MIL1/097 (WIND!); Karasburg Distr.: 20
km (12.25 miles) NNE of Grünau, 13 Oct. 1949, Acocks
15562 (PRE, WIND!); Farm Vrede, 19 July 2005, Bruyns
10106 (BOL, WIND!); Farm Witpütz WAR 258, 15 May
1963, Giess, Volk & Bleissner 6951 (WIND!); Farm
Genadendal, WAR 264, 20 May 1972, Giess & Müller
12087 (PRE, WIND!); Farm Sandfontein, WAR 148, 5
Aug. 1976, Giess 14505 (PRE, WIND!); 16 km SE of
gate to Farm Pioneer homestead along WarmbadOnseepkans road, 8 Sept. 2005, Kolberg & Tholkes
HK1663 (K!, WIND!); Farm Aussenkehr, 13 km along
German Outpost Trail (NE) from Noordoewer road,
18 Oct. 2005, Kolberg & Tholkes HK1728 (K!, WIND!);
Farm Udabis, 15 Oct. 1979, Lind 482 (WIND!); Farm
Sperlingspütz. No. 259, 21 Sept. 1979, Owen Smith 1209
(WIND!); Lüderitz Distr.: Aus – Rosh Pinah Road, ± 7
km from Aus, on road verge, 2 Aug. 2002, Bartsch
SB890a (WIND!); Rosh Pinah. Nooitgedacht, 10 Aug.
2000, Bruyns 8332 (BOL, WIND!); Sperrgebiet, SW
corner of Letterkuppe Mts, 9 Sept. 2003, Burke 03182
(WIND!); Gubub [Kubub], July 1897, Dinter 1233 (P.
unguiculata holotype BM-001114681!, isotype Z000003820!); Kubub, Aus, 4 Oct. 1959, Giess 2388
(PRE, WIND!); N of Aus, quartz ridge, 28 Sept. 1975,
Giess 13738 (PRE, WIND!); Farm Weissenborn LU 45,
slopes of Rietrivier, 10 July 1940, Kinges 2468 (PRE,
WIND!); Farm Plateau, found in the saddle in front of
the farmhouse. Aus, Sept. 1963, Kräusel & Wiss 2012
(WIND!); Klein Aus Vista campsite koppies, Oct. 2002,
Mannheimer CM2285 (WIND!); Paddaput, E of house,
21 Sept. 2004, Mannheimer, Maggs-Kölling & Loots
CM2616 (WIND!); (Aus) Quartz foothills, 17 Sept.
2005, Mannheimer CM2820 (WIND!); Aus, found on
the mountains on farm Klein-Aus, 18 Aug. 1963,
Merxmüller & Giess 2968 (M, PRE, WIND!); Gross
Namaland, Aus, 17 Nov. 1884, Schenck 203 (Z!);
Khomas Region, Windhoek Distr.: Farm Areb-Nord
REH 202, Nauchas, 30 Aug. 1972, Merxmüller & Giess
28113 (M, PRE, WIND!).
HABITAT. Rocky mountains in desert, desert-dwarf
shrub transition, dwarf shrub savanna, dwarf shrubland, escarpment and steppe characterised by succulent species; 500 – 1700 m.
CONSERVATION STATUS. This is the most widespread
species of Pteronia in Namibia with an estimated EOO at
least 40-fold the maximum for a status of VU under
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
criterion B1 (IUCN 2013). Populations are fairly large
and the estimated AOO also much larger than required
for classification in a threatened category. No threats are
identified that negatively affect population size, further
disqualifying P. unguiculata as a threatened species
under the IUCN (2001) system. The Namibian conservation status therefore is LC (IUCN 2001, 2013). The
South African threat status is also LC (SANBI 2011).
PHENOLOGY. Flowering: March to November. Fruiting:
July to January.
USES. Browsed by animals.
NOTES. The species seems to be closely related to
Pteronia mucronata (Merxmüller 1952) but the absence
of bristles on the leaves in P. unguiculata distinguishes
the two species (Fig. 14); see also the discussion under
P. mucronata. Specimens from the Brandberg show most
similarities with P. mucronata but the leaves are not at all
ciliate or pectinate. From a phytogeographical point of
view these specimens would also better fit into P.
mucronata, another high altitude species found to the
south of the Brandberg (see Map 13). In his description
of the species Moore (1904) discussed the similarity of P.
unguiculata and P. cylindracea (q.v.), claiming there is a
clear distinction in the shape of the capitula (short,
narrowly ovoid in P. unguiculata (Fig. 14), long, strictly
cylindrical in P. cylindracea) and apices of phyllaries
(entire or very nearly so in P. unguiculata, ciliate-lacerate
in P. cylindracea). This distinction is, unfortunately, not
always that clear in Namibian material.
24. Pteronia viscosa Thunb. (Thunberg 1800: 144); de
Candolle (1836: 364); Harvey in Harvey & Sonder
(1865: 108); Hutchinson & Phillips (1917: 306);
Merxmüller (1967: 159); Merxmüller & Roessler
(1984: 90); Herman (2003: 279). Type: South Africa,
Western Cape Prov., Cape of Good Hope, Thunberg
s.n. (holotype UPS-THUNB).
Shrub, to 60 cm tall. Stems glabrous, greyish-white. Leaves
opposite, thick, fleshy, glabrous except for keel and
sometimes lower surface that may be setulose-ciliate,
lanceolate to oblong-lanceolate, keeled, 8 – 10 × 4 mm;
apex slightly mucronate, base slightly connate; margins
and keel bristly-ciliate. Capitula solitary, terminal, obconic,
20 – 25 × 15 mm. Receptacle honeycombed. Phyllaries
multiseriate, outer broadly ovate, scaly, apex subacute,
inner linear-lanceolate, membranous, apex acute; 8 – 15
mm long, rugulose distally on outside. Florets c. 15; corollas
to 12 mm long, glabrous, yellow; lobes ovate-lanceolate,
subacute; tube slender, slightly angular at base. Achenes
compressed, obovoid, ribbed, glabrous or with a few hairs
on ribs, to 7 × 4 mm. Pappus c. 12 mm long, straw-coloured.
DISTRIBUTION. Africa: Namibia (uncertain — see
Notes), South Africa. Map 24.
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
SPECIMENS EXAMINED. SOUTH AFRICA. Eastern Cape
Prov.: Uitenhage, Zeyher 98 (P!); Western Cape Prov.:
Matjiesvalei, Drège s.n. (P-027299!); Zwart Ruggens,
Drège s.n.[5661] (P-027299! to -301!); Cap de Bonne
Espérance, Ecklon s.n. (P-027302!).
HABITAT. Steppe dominated by a diversity of succulent
species.
CONSERVATION STATUS. There is only one specimen
reported to be from Namibia (Pearson 3677); however,
as this could not be found and occurrence in Namibia
is not entirely certain, no assessment can be made of
the species’ status in Namibia, which therefore has to
be Not Evaluated (NE) (IUCN 2001). The South
African threat status is recorded as LC (SANBI 2011).
VERNACULAR NAMES. Gombossie (Afrikaans, South Africa).
NOTES. According to the specimens cited by Hutchinson
& Phillips (1917: 307), this species occurs in Namibia.
Their cited specimen (Pearson 3677, Karas Region,
Lüderitz District: Great Namaqualand, 18 km W of
Aus) could, however, not be traced in NBG, K, PRE,
SAM or WIND, and its occurrence in Namibia could
therefore not be verified. In South Africa the species
occurs in the Western and Eastern Cape Provinces,
disjunct from the Namibian locality of Pearson 3677.
According to Pearson (1911) he spent time at this
locality on 20 February 1909. Other Pearson specimens
from that time have collector’s numbers far removed
from 3677 (in the 4- or 5-thousands). Specimens with
numbers close to 3677 were collected far from the Aus
locality or during different years. It is therefore possible
that there is some error and that this species does not
occur in Namibia. The Pearson locality (18 km W of Aus)
needs to be searched to clarify this issue.
9488, Page 41 of 44
Pteronia species reported from Namibia but no longer
belonging to the genus
Pteronia aizoides Muschl. (Muschler 1911a: 102). Type:
Bezirk [Distr.] of Great Namaqualand, Dinter 1388
(holotype B†; isotype K!, located in unsorted Pteronia
collections and rather poor material, consisting of
loose leaves and seeds with pappus only). Currently a
synonym of Eremothamnus marlothianus O. Hoffm.
Pteronia engleriana Muschl. (Muschler 1911a: 98,
“Engleriana”); Dinter (1926: 132, “Engleriana”);
Range (1935: 275, “Engleri”). Type: Bezirk [Distr.] of
Great Namaqualand, Aus, in 1400 m Meereshöhe,
Dinte (the -r is missing) 1107 (holotype B†; isotypes
SAM-071501, K-000415078!). Currently a synonym of
Amphiglossa tomentosa (Thunb.) Harv.
Pteronia geigerioides Muschl. ex Dinter (1926: 132); Range
(1935: 275), nom. nud. Bremer (1983: 195) considered
it a synonym of Asaemia minuta (L. f.) K. Bremer, while
Källersjö (1991: 39) placed it under the now accepted
Athanasia minuta (L. f.) Källersjö subsp. minuta.
Pteronia marlothiana (O. Hoffm.) Dinter (1926: 132);
Range (1935: 275). Type: [Namibia] Namaland,
Angra Pequena [Lüderitz and environs], in saxosis
desertis, alt. 10 m, florif. m. Aprili 1886, Marloth 1154
(lectotype (chosen for Eremothamnus marlothianus) PRE0206236-0!, selected here; isolectotypes NBG-02002550!, SAM-0039695-0!, PRE-0594888-0!). Marloth collections from SW Africa are reported from L, M, OXF, and
PRE (Vegter 1976: 504). In this particular case they
were not found in (K or) L, M, or OXF, but NBG, PRE
and SAM did have what are effectively isotypes. The
PRE collections are considered the original set of
Marloth’s material (Glen & Germishuizen 2009: 286)
and hence the PRE copy of 1154 is chosen as lectotype.
Currently its accepted identity is that of the basionym
Eremothamnus marlothianus O. Hoffm.
Pteronia minuta L. f. (Linnaeus filius 1782: 357). Type:
(South Africa) Cap. bonæ spei” [Cape of Good
Hope], Thunberg 18977 (holotype UPS-THUNB,
selected by Bremer 1983: 195). Distribution maps
presented by Bremer (1983) and Källersjö (1991)
show presence in Namibia. Currently the basionym
of Athanasia minuta (L. f.) Källersjö subsp. minuta.
Map 24. Reported but unconfirmed distribution of Pteronia
viscosa in Namibia.
Conclusions
Some uncertainties still exist on the status of some of
the Namibian species of Pteronia and more specimens
from outside Namibia need to be studied to clarify these
issues. A revision of this largely African genus over its
entire range is needed. For this synopsis many specimens
were seen only as high-resolution photographs and
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 42 of 44
although these are a tremendous help, they cannot
completely replace looking at the real thing.
Acknowledgements
The Millennium Seed Bank Partnership is acknowledged for funding of fieldtrips. In Namibia the
Ministry of Environment and Tourism is thanked for
the plant collecting permit and the National Botanical
Research Institute (NBRI), Ministry of Agriculture,
Water and Forestry for use of their facilities. Patricia
Craven was very helpful in obtaining additional
information, literature and specimen photographs
and getting some of the herbarium specimen data
onto a BRAHMS database, while Tyrone Tholkes is
gratefully acknowledged for assistance during fieldwork. At Kew we are grateful to Juliet Beentje for her
wonderful line drawings of five Pteronia species, to Dr
Nicholas Hind for advice on Compositae terminology
and for help with identifying suitable herbarium
material for some of the line drawings, to Rafaël
Govaerts for his help with some nomenclatural
tangles, and to Dr Wolfgang Stuppy for his improvement of the images and maps. Furthermore, we thank
Dr Dee Snijman (NBG, Cape Town) for her search for
Pteronia, Amphiglossa, Athanasia and Eremothamnus specimens at SAM and NBG, Mr Paul Herman (PRE) for
advice on Eremothamnus, Mr John Hunnex for finding
two Pteronia holotypes in BM, and Mr Thomas
Hillmann for providing a photograph of Dinter 6190
while Herbarium Hamburgense was off-line. At the
herbarium G in Geneva Drs Fernand Jacquemoud
and Matthieu Perret, as well as Sylviane Mura are
thanked for their invaluable help in checking the
many Candolle types in G-DC involved in this study
and making them available through high-resolution
images. HK thanks the curators of K, NBG, SAM and
WIND for making their collections available for study.
We thank the three reviewers for useful suggestions
and improvements.
References
Bergius, P. J. (1767). Descriptiones Plantarum ex Capite
Bonæ Spei. L. Salvius, Stockholm.
Bremer, K. (1983). Taxonomy of Asaemia with notes
on Stilnophyton (Compositae-Anthemideae). Nord. J.
Bot. 3: 193 – 195.
____ (1994). Asteraceae, cladistics & classification. Timber
Press, Portland, Oregon.
Brown, N. E. (1906). XVIII – Diagnoses Africanae,
XVI. Bull. Misc. Inform., Kew 1906: 98 – 109.
Craven, P. & Loots, S. (2002). Namibia. In: J. S.
Golding (ed.), Southern African Plant Red Data Lists.
Southern African Botanical Diversity Network Report 14: 61 – 92.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
de Candolle, A. P. (1836). Prodromus Systematis
Naturalis Regni Vegetabilis, Pars Quinta. Treuttel &
Würtz, Paris. [Pteronia L. on pp. 356 – 365]
Dinter, K. (1921). LVIII. Index der aus DeutschSüdwestafrika bis zum Jahre 1917 bekannt
gewordenen Pflanzenarten. VII. Repert. Spec. Nov.
Regni Veg. 17: 185 – 192.
____ (1926). VI. Index der aus Deutsch-Südwestafrika bis
zum Jahre 1917 bekannt gewordenen Pflanzenarten.
XX. Repert. Spec. Nov. Regni Veg. 23: 130 – 133.
____ (1931). Kurzer Bericht über meine Reise 1929 in
die Küstenwüste SW.-Afrikas, spez. die Buchuberge.
Repert. Spec. Nov. Regni Veg. 29: 163 – 170.
____ (1932). XVI. Diagnosen neuer südwestafrikanischer
Pflanzen. 2. Fortsetzung. Repert. Spec. Nov. Regni Veg.
30: 181 – 184.
Drège, J. F. (1843). Zwei pflanzengeographische
Documente. Besondere Beigabe zur Flora 1843 Band
II: 1 – 230. Königliche Botanische Gesellschaft,
Regensburg. [With an introduction by […nebst
einer Einleitung von…] E. Meyer, on pp. 3 – 43]
Glen, H. F. & Germishuizen, G. (2009). Botanical exploration of southern Africa — edition 2. Strelitzia 26: 286.
Harvey, W. H. (1865). Compositae. In: W. H. Harvey &
O. W. Sonder (eds), Flora Capensis Volume III,
Rubiaceae to Campanulaceae. Hodges, Smith and
Co., Dublin. [Pteronia on pp. 95 – 110]
Herman, P. P. J. (2003). Pteronia. In: G. Germishuizen
& N. L. Meyer (eds), Plants of southern Africa: an
annotated checklist. Strelitzia 14: 276 – 279.
____, Retief, E., Koekemoer, M. & Welman, W. G. (2000).
Asteraceae. In: O. A. Leistner (ed.), Seed Plants of
southern Africa: families and genera. Strelitzia 10: 101 –
170.
Hoffmann, O. (1893). Pteronia polygalifolia. In: H.
Schinz (ed.), Beiträge zur Kenntnis der
Afrikanischen Flora. Bull. Herb. Boissier 1: 73.
Hutchinson, J. & Phillips, E. P. (1917). A revision of
the genus Pteronia (Compositae). Ann. S. African
Mus. 9: 277 – 329.
IUCN (2001). IUCN Red List Categories and Criteria.
Version 3.1. IUCN Species Survival Commission.
IUCN, Gland & Cambridge.
IUCN Standards and Petitions Subcommittee (2013).
Guidelines for Using the IUCN Red List Categories
and Criteria. Version 10. Prepared by the Standards
and Petitions Subcommittee. Downloadable
from http://www.iucnredlist.org/documents/
RedListGuidelines.pdf.
Källersjö, M. (1991). The genus Athanasia (Compositae –
Anthemideae). Opera Bot. 106: 1 – 75.
Klatt, F. W. (1896). Tribus: Mutisiaceae. In: H. Schinz
(ed.), Beiträge zur Kenntnis der Afrikanischen
Flora. Bull. Herb. Boissier 4: 843.
Lanjouw, J. & Stafleu, F. A. (1954). Index Herbariorum,
Part II(1), Collectors, First instalment A – D. Reg.
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
Veget. 2: 163. Utrecht – Netherlands: International Bureau for Plant Taxonomy and Nomenclature of the International Association for Plant
Taxonomy.
____ & ____ (1957). Index Herbariorum, Part II(2),
Collectors, E – H. Reg. Veget. 9: 176.
Lessing, C. F. (1832). Synopsis Generum Compositarum,
Berolini, Sumtibus Dunckeri et Humblotii, Paris &
London. [Pteronia on pp. 195 – 196]
Linnaeus, C. (1760). Plantae Rariores Africanæ. L.
Salvius, Stockholm. [Thesis of Jacob Printz, presided over by Linnaeus to whom new names have to
be attributed]
____ (1763a). Amoenitates academicæ, vol. 6. L. Salvius,
Stockholm. [The thesis of Jacob Printz, cited as
Plantae africanæ rariores, as no. 106 on pp. 77 –
115]
____ (1763b). Species plantarum (ed. 2) Vol. 2. L.
Salvius, Stockholm.
____ (1764). Genera Plantarum. L. Salvius, Stockholm.
Linnaeus, C. (filius) (1782). Supplementum Plantarum.
Impensis Orphanotrophei, Brunsvigæ. [Title page
“1781” but published April 1782]
Loots, S. (2005). Red Data Book of Namibian Plants.
Southern African Botanical Diversity Network Report 38: 37, 122.
Lowrey, T. K. (1998). Pteronia. In: C. E. Jarvis & N. J.
Turland (eds), Typification of Linnaean specific
and varietal names in the Compositae (Asteraceae).
Taxon 47: 365.
Merxmüller, H. (1952). Compositen Studien II. Mitt.
Bot. Staatssamml. München 1: 120 – 129.
____ (1955). Pteronia. In: K. Suessenguth & H.
Merxmüller (eds), Taxa praecipue africana. Mitt.
Bot. Staatssamml. München 2: 67 – 83.
____ (1967). 139: Asteraceae. In: H. Merxmüller (ed.),
Prodromus einer Flora von Südwestafrika. J. Cramer, Lehre.
____ & Roessler, H. (1984). Compositen-Studien XI.
Neue Übersicht der Compositen Südwestafrikas.
Mitt. Bot. Staatssamml. München 20: 61 – 96.
Moore, S. (1902). A contribution to the Composite
flora of Africa. J. Linn. Soc., Bot. 35: 325 – 326.
____ (1904). Compositae. Bull. Herb. Boissier Ser. II. 4:
1011 – 1013.
Muschler, R. (1911a). Compositae africanae novae. I.
Bot. Jahrb. Syst. 46: 51 – 124. [Pteronia on pp. 95 – 103]
____ (1911b). LXXXVII. Vernonia De Wildemaniana
Muschler, nom. nov. Repert. Spec. Nov. Regni Veg. 9: 384.
Nordenstam, B. (1971). New South African Compositae.
Bot. Not. 124: 10 – 14.
Pearson, H. H. W. (1911). 1. On the collections of
dried plants obtained in South-West Africa by the
Percy Sladen Memorial Expeditions, 1908 – 1911.
Ann. S. African Mus. 9: 1 – 20.
Range, P. (1935). Die Flora des Namalandes. VIII.
Repert. Spec. Nov. Regni Veg. 38: 256 – 280.
9488, Page 43 of 44
Roessler, H. & Merxmüller, H. (1982). Weitere
Neufunde aus Südwestafrika. Mitt. Bot. Staatssamml.
München 18: 187 – 200.
South African National Biodiversity Institute
(SANBI). (2011). SANBI Integrated Biodiversity
Information System (SIBIS). Website http://
sibis.sanbi.org/faces/Home.jsp?1=1. Accessed 2
December 2012.
Stafleu, F. A. & Cowan, R. S. (1986). Taxonomic
literature. Volume VI: Sti – Vuy, p. 538. Bohn,
Scheltema & Holkema, Utrecht/Antwerpen; Dr.
W. Junk b.v., Publishers, The Hague/Boston.
Thunberg, C. P. (1800). Prodromus Plantarum
Capensium, quas, in Promontorio Bonæ Spei Africes,
annis 1772 – 1775. Pars posterior. Joh. Fr. Edman,
Uppsala.
Turczaninow, N. S. (1851). Synanthereae quaedam
hucusque indescriptae. Bull. Soc. Imp. Naturalistes
Moscou 24: 59 – 95.
Turland, N. J. (2013). The Code decoded. A user’s guide to the
International Code of Nomenclature for algae, fungi, and
plants. Koeltz Scientific Books, Königstein.
Vegter, I. H. (1976). Index Herbariorum, Part II(4),
Collectors, M. Regnum Veg. 93: 504. Bohn, Scheltema
& Holkema, Utrecht.
Index of plant names
Accepted names in bold; synonyms in italics.
Chrysocoma oppositifolia L. = Pteronia divaricata Less.
Dicoma ramosissima Klatt = Pteronia acuminata DC.
Dicoma seitziana Dinter = Pteronia eenii S. Moore
Eupatorium divaricatum P. J. Bergius = Pteronia divaricata
Less.
Pteronia acuminata DC.
Pteronia acuta Muschl.
Pteronia aizoides Muschl. = Eremothamnus marlothianus
O. Hoffm.
Pteronia anisata B. Nord.
Pteronia anisata Dinter ex Merxm., nom. nud. =
Pteronia glabrata L. f.
Pteronia arcuata Dinter = Pteronia glauca Thunb.
Pteronia beckeoides auct. non DC. = Pteronia lucilioides DC.
Pteronia bromoides S. Moore = Pteronia lucilioides DC.
Pteronia cancellata Dinter, nom. nud. = Pteronia pomonae
Merxm.
Pteronia candollei Harv. = Pteronia glauca Thunb.
Pteronia carnosa Muschl. (Muschler 1911a: 95) non
P. carnosa Muschl. (Muschler 1911a: 97) = Pteronia
glabrata L. f.
Pteronia carnosa Muschl. (Muschler 1911a: 97) non
P. carnosa Muschl. (Muschler 1911a: 95). = Pteronia
acuminata DC.
Pteronia chlorolepis Dinter = Pteronia sordida N. E. Br.
Pteronia ciliata Thunb.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
9488, Page 44 of 44
Pteronia ciliata Thunb. var. ecklonis Harv. = Pteronia ciliata
Thunb.
Pteronia ciliata Thunb. var. subtrigona DC. = Pteronia ciliata
Thunb.
Pteronia ciliata Thunb. var. thunbergii Harv. = Pteronia
ciliata Thunb.
Pteronia cylindracea DC.
Pteronia dinteri S. Moore = Pteronia mucronata DC.
Pteronia divaricata Less.
Pteronia eenii S. Moore
Pteronia engleriana Muschl. = Amphiglossa tomentosa
(Thunb.) Harv.
Pteronia feddeana Muschl. = Pteronia acuminata DC.
Pteronia feldtmanniana Dinter ex Merxm., nom. nud. =
Pteronia eenii S. Moore
Pteronia flexicaulis auct. non L. f. = Pteronia paniculata
Thunb.
Pteronia geigerioides Muschl. ex Dinter, nom. nud. =
Athanasia minuta (L. f.) Källersjö
Pteronia glabrata L. f.
Pteronia glabrata auct. non L. f. = Pteronia glauca
Thunb.
Pteronia glabrata L. f. var. succulenta (Thunb.) Merxm. =
Pteronia glabrata L. f.
Pteronia glauca Thunb.
Pteronia glauca Thunb. subsp. arcuata (Dinter) Merxm. =
Pteronia glauca Thunb.
Pteronia glomerata, auct. non L. f. = Pteronia sordida
N. E. Br.
Pteronia gymnocline auct. non DC. = Pteronia lucilioides
DC.
Pteronia inflexa L. f.
Pteronia kingesii Merxm. = Pteronia polygalifolia O. Hoffm.
Pteronia latisquama DC. = Pteronia glauca Thunb.
Pteronia leucoclada Turcz.
Pteronia lucilioides DC.
© The Board of Trustees of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 2014
KEW BULLETIN (2014) 69: 9488
Pteronia lucilioides DC. var. sparsifolia Harv. = Pteronia
lucilioides DC.
Pteronia lupulina DC. = Pteronia inflexa L. f.
Pteronia lupulina DC. var. rotundifolia DC. = Pteronia
inflexa L. f.
Pteronia lycioides Muschl. ex Dinter = Pteronia scariosa L. f.
Pteronia marlothiana (O. Hoffm.) Dinter = Eremothamnus
marlothianus O. Hoffm.
Pteronia minuta L. f. = Athanasia minuta (L. f.) Källersjö
subsp. minuta
Pteronia mucronata DC.
Pteronia mucronata DC. subsp. dinteri (S. Moore) Merxm. =
Pteronia mucronata DC.
Pteronia onobromoides DC.
Pteronia paniculata Thunb.
Pteronia polygalifolia O. Hoffm.
Pteronia pomonae Merxm.
Pteronia quadrifaria Dinter
Pteronia quinquecostata Dinter = Pteronia polygalifolia
O. Hoffm.
Pteronia rangei Muschl.
Pteronia roesemanniana Dinter ex Merxm., nom. nud. =
Pteronia lucilioides DC.
Pteronia scariosa L. f.
Pteronia sesuviifolia DC. = Pteronia glabrata L. f.
Pteronia sordida N. E. Br.
Pteronia spinulosa E. Phillips
Pteronia succulenta auct. non Thunb. = Pteronia glabrata
L. f.
Pteronia thymifolia Muschl. & Dinter = Pteronia glauca
Thunb.
Pteronia turbinata DC. = Pteronia ciliata Thunb.
Pteronia unguiculata S. Moore
Pteronia villosa auct. non L. f. = Pteronia pomonae
Merxm.
Pteronia viscosa Thunb.